Scratch

726961 · 2008-12-26 15:00:04

It seems like we have most loved, top viewed, most downloaded, newest, random, and featured as part of front page. Why not most tagged projects? if you agree say something below.

726961 · 2008-12-26 15:02:59

something

Buddy_ca111 · 2008-12-26 17:58:30

I would disagree with that. Because why would there be a top tagged? People would tag the project with tags that have to do nothing with the project and it would be harder to search on scratch.

yambanshee · 2008-12-27 03:42:33

exactly. people will tag their own projects to get up...

jamie · 2008-12-27 13:49:08

waffles
waffles2
waffles3
waffles4
waffles5
waffles6
waffles7
waffles8
......

What would be the point?

technoguyx · 2008-12-27 16:05:44

jamie wrote:
waffles
waffles2
waffles3
waffles4
waffles5
waffles6
waffles7
waffles8
......

What would be the point?

...Exactly.

726961 · 2008-12-27 19:25:34

hadn't thought of that... maybe most individual persons to tag a project?

(don't hurt me)

Zelda123 · 2008-12-27 19:31:24

726961 wrote:
hadn't thought of that... maybe most individual persons to tag a project?

(don't hurt me)

So you mean most taggers?

There still is not much point to that as tags don't really show how "good" a project is. People may tag a project because they find it good or bad or okay- tags don't really show that a project is worth the front page. Also, the projects that receive the most tags will most likely already be on the front page, because more views means more chances that people will add a tag.

yoshi14 · 2008-12-29 11:09:13

Zelda123 wrote:
726961 wrote:
hadn't thought of that... maybe most individual persons to tag a project?

(don't hurt me)
So you mean most taggers?

There still is not much point to that as tags don't really show how "good" a project is. People may tag a project because they find it good or bad or okay- tags don't really show that a project is worth the front page. Also, the projects that receive the most tags will most likely already be on the front page, because more views means more chances that people will add a tag.

how about most recently tagged projects. Like most viewed. there is not the most viewed project on scratch there always. Just the most recently viewed?

Zelda123 · 2008-12-29 12:01:41

yoshi14 wrote:
Zelda123 wrote:
726961 wrote:
hadn't thought of that... maybe most individual persons to tag a project?

(don't hurt me)
So you mean most taggers?

There still is not much point to that as tags don't really show how "good" a project is. People may tag a project because they find it good or bad or okay- tags don't really show that a project is worth the front page. Also, the projects that receive the most tags will most likely already be on the front page, because more views means more chances that people will add a tag.
how about most recently tagged projects. Like most viewed. there is not the most viewed project on scratch there always. Just the most recently viewed?

There are no all-time anything categories shown on the front page...still what would the "most tagged" projects show?

726961 · 2008-12-29 13:33:10

Zelda123 wrote:
yoshi14 wrote:
Zelda123 wrote:
So you mean most taggers?

There still is not much point to that as tags don't really show how "good" a project is. People may tag a project because they find it good or bad or okay- tags don't really show that a project is worth the front page. Also, the projects that receive the most tags will most likely already be on the front page, because more views means more chances that people will add a tag.
how about most recently tagged projects. Like most viewed. there is not the most viewed project on scratch there always. Just the most recently viewed?
There are no all-time anything categories shown on the front page...still what would the "most tagged" projects show?

I think he means if you click on see more, there is the most ______ project. I really don't know exactly what most tagged project would mean, I just wondering if there is a tag place might as well make use of it.

Last edited by 726961 (2008-12-29 13:33:39)

Zelda123 · 2008-12-29 13:43:31

726961 wrote:
Zelda123 wrote:
yoshi14 wrote:

how about most recently tagged projects. Like most viewed. there is not the most viewed project on scratch there always. Just the most recently viewed?
There are no all-time anything categories shown on the front page...still what would the "most tagged" projects show?
I think he means if you click on see more, there is the most ______ project. I really don't know exactly what most tagged project would mean, I just wondering if there is a tag place might as well make use of it.

The tags have a great use. Everytime a revelant tag is added, users will be able to find that project more easily through the search bar.

bhz · 2008-12-29 15:11:51

yambanshee wrote:
exactly. people will tag their own projects to get up...

People can replatedly download their own projects to get to most downloaded. People can repeatedly refresh the project page to get on most viewed.

itsmyhammie · 2008-12-29 15:12:12

I don't think it's a good idea because any random person can get top tagged if they tag it millions of times. Plus, why?

Zelda123 · 2008-12-29 15:31:38

bhz wrote:
yambanshee wrote:
exactly. people will tag their own projects to get up...
People can replatedly download their own projects to get to most downloaded. People can repeatedly refresh the project page to get on most viewed.

No, it is one view per IP Address (every 24 hours)
No, it is one download per IP Address/Account
The only way to "cheat" right now is creating dummy accounts to love your own projects but there leads to other problems...

726961 · 2008-12-30 11:59:20

itsmyhammie wrote:
I don't think it's a good idea because any random person can get top tagged if they tag it millions of times. Plus, why?

most different people tagging a project. well there are tags so we might as well put them to use.

adtron5678 · 2011-01-10 19:16:04

Zelda123 wrote:
726961 wrote:
hadn't thought of that... maybe most individual persons to tag a project?

(don't hurt me)
So you mean most taggers?

There still is not much point to that as tags don't really show how "good" a project is. People may tag a project because they find it good or bad or okay- tags don't really show that a project is worth the front page. Also, the projects that receive the most tags will most likely already be on the front page, because more views means more chances that people will add a tag.

how many people view it dosen't mean it's "good" either
it just means people view it. smile

adtron5678 · 2011-01-10 19:17:19

Zelda123 wrote:
bhz wrote:
yambanshee wrote:
exactly. people will tag their own projects to get up...
People can replatedly download their own projects to get to most downloaded. People can repeatedly refresh the project page to get on most viewed.
No, it is one view per IP Address (every 24 hours)
No, it is one download per IP Address/Account
The only way to "cheat" right now is creating dummy accounts to love your own projects but there leads to other problems...

on some computers you could just keep changing your ip big_smile

ssss · 2011-01-11 05:45:28

adtron5678 wrote:
Zelda123 wrote:
bhz wrote:

People can replatedly download their own projects to get to most downloaded. People can repeatedly refresh the project page to get on most viewed.
No, it is one view per IP Address (every 24 hours)
No, it is one download per IP Address/Account
The only way to "cheat" right now is creating dummy accounts to love your own projects but there leads to other problems...
on some computers you could just keep changing your ip

Or use whatymaccallits Don't kill me IE users -- Proxys

Scratch

archived forums

#1 2008-12-26 15:00:04

a most tagged front page piece

#2 2008-12-26 15:02:59

Re: a most tagged front page piece

#3 2008-12-26 17:58:30

Re: a most tagged front page piece

#4 2008-12-27 03:42:33

Re: a most tagged front page piece

#5 2008-12-27 13:49:08

Re: a most tagged front page piece

#6 2008-12-27 16:05:44

Re: a most tagged front page piece

jamie wrote:

#7 2008-12-27 19:25:34

Re: a most tagged front page piece

#8 2008-12-27 19:31:24

Re: a most tagged front page piece

726961 wrote:

#9 2008-12-29 11:09:13

Re: a most tagged front page piece

Zelda123 wrote:

726961 wrote:

#10 2008-12-29 12:01:41

Re: a most tagged front page piece

yoshi14 wrote:

Zelda123 wrote:

726961 wrote:

#11 2008-12-29 13:33:10

Re: a most tagged front page piece

Zelda123 wrote:

yoshi14 wrote:

Zelda123 wrote:

#12 2008-12-29 13:43:31

Re: a most tagged front page piece

726961 wrote:

Zelda123 wrote:

yoshi14 wrote:

#13 2008-12-29 15:11:51

Re: a most tagged front page piece

yambanshee wrote:

#14 2008-12-29 15:12:12

Re: a most tagged front page piece

#15 2008-12-29 15:31:38

Re: a most tagged front page piece

bhz wrote:

yambanshee wrote:

#16 2008-12-30 11:59:20

Re: a most tagged front page piece

itsmyhammie wrote:

#17 2011-01-10 19:16:04

Re: a most tagged front page piece

Zelda123 wrote:

726961 wrote:

#18 2011-01-10 19:17:19

Re: a most tagged front page piece

Zelda123 wrote:

bhz wrote:

yambanshee wrote:

#19 2011-01-11 05:45:28

Re: a most tagged front page piece

adtron5678 wrote:

Zelda123 wrote:

bhz wrote:

Board footer