Pages: 1 2
Topic closed
Which is better? (in your opinion)
Last edited by Flaming_Trout_Inc (2010-01-02 18:53:43)
Offline
Curator spot, because anything can get Top Loved or viewed. Only the good shtuff gets in the curator spot.
Offline
floatingmagictree wrote:
Curator spot, because anything can get Top Loved or viewed. Only the good shtuff gets in the curator spot.
No not really
Some curators used favoritism in their picks
Offline
ScratchX wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
Curator spot, because anything can get Top Loved or viewed. Only the good shtuff gets in the curator spot.
No not really
![]()
Some curators used favoritism in their picks
Example pl0x?
Offline
Curator is an actual person's opinion that is respected by the scratch team. Top viewed and top loved are the opinions of many people who like unfunny animations better than anything else.
You should be proud of being curated.
Offline
floatingmagictree wrote:
ScratchX wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
Curator spot, because anything can get Top Loved or viewed. Only the good shtuff gets in the curator spot.
No not really
![]()
Some curators used favoritism in their picksExample pl0x?
Like if you looked at some past curators.
some of them have picked projects from their friends first
Offline
ScratchX wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
ScratchX wrote:
No not really
![]()
Some curators used favoritism in their picksExample pl0x?
Like if you looked at some past curators.
some of them have picked projects from their friends first
Only one that I found is Penguinsrock.
Offline
floatingmagictree wrote:
ScratchX wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
Example pl0x?
Like if you looked at some past curators.
some of them have picked projects from their friends firstOnly one that I found is Penguinsrock.
Well then there's your example
Offline
I'd say top loved,because anyone can get views,while love-its don't come randomly.Curator is also very good,as it means a respected scratcher admires your project and appreciates your effort in it.
Offline
I like Curator and Featured. :-D
Offline
floatingmagictree wrote:
ScratchX wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
Example pl0x?Like if you looked at some past curators.
some of them have picked projects from their friends firstOnly one that I found is Penguinsrock.
I find that very offending. Don't point my name. I think that those projects on my friends list were very helpful, I used those to stall as I was going to find more. They said to choose atleast 2 each week, so I used those as a stall, so I can find that. They do not have to be complex to be found. I know curators that chose projects that were already very popular in the past, sure it' be nice to put them there for newer users, but that's not giving others a chance! But would the curator like it if I pointed out there name? No. Not at all. I have nothing against them, so there.
Offline
Penguinsrock wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
ScratchX wrote:
Like if you looked at some past curators.
some of them have picked projects from their friends firstOnly one that I found is Penguinsrock.
I find that very offending. Don't point my name. I think that those projects on my friends list were very helpful, I used those to stall as I was going to find more. They said to choose atleast 2 each week, so I used those as a stall, so I can find that. They do not have to be complex to be found. I know curators that chose projects that were already very popular in the past, sure it' be nice to put them there for newer users, but that's not giving others a chance! But would the curator like it if I pointed out there name? No. Not at all. I have nothing against them, so there.
The first thing I would do as curator would be to curate Combinebobnt's Apocalyptic Whatever - cuz he deserves it, not because he's my friend.
Offline
RHY3756547 wrote:
Penguinsrock wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
Only one that I found is Penguinsrock.I find that very offending. Don't point my name. I think that those projects on my friends list were very helpful, I used those to stall as I was going to find more. They said to choose atleast 2 each week, so I used those as a stall, so I can find that. They do not have to be complex to be found. I know curators that chose projects that were already very popular in the past, sure it' be nice to put them there for newer users, but that's not giving others a chance! But would the curator like it if I pointed out there name? No. Not at all. I have nothing against them, so there.
The first thing I would do as curator would be to curate Combinebobnt's Apocalyptic Whatever - cuz he deserves it, not because he's my friend.
You don't understand my reasons. This is another reason of possible leaving for me. I'm already sick and tired of drama, but where the drama comes from is where I usually go. The second is these people who can't understand us artists and animations, and me, I usually agree with the oppisate opinions, but it always offends me anyway. Please do not call me a whiner, that cause me to just 'whine' more. I felt very respected when I got featured the first time, and I was so happy to be curator. Reading FMT's post made me regret that.
Offline
MyRedNeptune wrote:
I like Curator and Featured. :-D
well of course featured.
everyone likes that

Offline
funkymonkey wrote:
MyRedNeptune wrote:
I like Curator and Featured. :-D
well of course featured.
everyone likes that
Bleh - only simple things get featured.
Offline
Penguinsrock wrote:
RHY3756547 wrote:
Penguinsrock wrote:
I find that very offending. Don't point my name. I think that those projects on my friends list were very helpful, I used those to stall as I was going to find more. They said to choose atleast 2 each week, so I used those as a stall, so I can find that. They do not have to be complex to be found. I know curators that chose projects that were already very popular in the past, sure it' be nice to put them there for newer users, but that's not giving others a chance! But would the curator like it if I pointed out there name? No. Not at all. I have nothing against them, so there.The first thing I would do as curator would be to curate Combinebobnt's Apocalyptic Whatever - cuz he deserves it, not because he's my friend.
You don't understand my reasons. This is another reason of possible leaving for me. I'm already sick and tired of drama, but where the drama comes from is where I usually go. The second is these people who can't understand us artists and animations, and me, I usually agree with the oppisate opinions, but it always offends me anyway. Please do not call me a whiner, that cause me to just 'whine' more. I felt very respected when I got featured the first time, and I was so happy to be curator. Reading FMT's post made me regret that.
I agree with your reasons,I think that when being in the respected position of curator is seen as a bad thing then people are defintly being idiotic.I wouldn't know much about your other reasons though,because i've only recently begun to use forum posts non-related to my company or a problem a user is having.
Offline
yeah but i would like to be featured

Offline
funkymonkey wrote:
yeah but i would like to be featured
Yeah,featured is the best,but there's no way to get it outside of luck and andremsh's reccomendation thread.
Offline
Penguinsrock wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
ScratchX wrote:
Like if you looked at some past curators.
some of them have picked projects from their friends firstOnly one that I found is Penguinsrock.
I find that very offending. Don't point my name. I think that those projects on my friends list were very helpful, I used those to stall as I was going to find more. They said to choose atleast 2 each week, so I used those as a stall, so I can find that. They do not have to be complex to be found. I know curators that chose projects that were already very popular in the past, sure it' be nice to put them there for newer users, but that's not giving others a chance! But would the curator like it if I pointed out there name? No. Not at all. I have nothing against them, so there.
We really like to see a variety of different selection styles from a variety of different curators. Please do not start second-guessing their choices. We want people to think of the curator spot as a fun way to show other people their interests and share projects they enjoy or learned from. If we start "pointing fingers" at specific curator decisions...it's not going to be fun for them and we are going to have a hard time finding new curators.
Please do tell us how you think the program can be improved...just leave the names out of the discussion. Thanks!
Offline
Paddle2See wrote:
Penguinsrock wrote:
floatingmagictree wrote:
Only one that I found is Penguinsrock.I find that very offending. Don't point my name. I think that those projects on my friends list were very helpful, I used those to stall as I was going to find more. They said to choose atleast 2 each week, so I used those as a stall, so I can find that. They do not have to be complex to be found. I know curators that chose projects that were already very popular in the past, sure it' be nice to put them there for newer users, but that's not giving others a chance! But would the curator like it if I pointed out there name? No. Not at all. I have nothing against them, so there.
We really like to see a variety of different selection styles from a variety of different curators. Please do not start second-guessing their choices. We want people to think of the curator spot as a fun way to show other people their interests and share projects they enjoy or learned from. If we start "pointing fingers" at specific curator decisions...it's not going to be fun for them and we are going to have a hard time finding new curators.
Thank you very much paddle2see. I think the new thread I posted will probably be closed though.....I had that idea much earlier than when I saw it, but I just got around to actually making it.
Offline
Looks like you edited your post.
How about interviewing the user through the email? That'd be a great way to find out if it's a good choice.
Offline
I think most loved recently is the best
My site Offline
Top Loved, because that means people cared enough on your project to love it
Offline
i only view the curator stuff, but it depends on the curator.
Offline
Topic closed
Pages: 1 2