Scratch

Flait7 · 2012-01-17 14:17:05

Game:
Programming:
Graphics:
Replay value:
Memorability:
Audio:
Storyline:
Animation:
Difficulty (easy):
Difficulty (hard):
Controls:
Originality:

Movie:
Programming:
Animation:
Storyline:
Audio:
Graphics:
Characters:
Originality:
Length:
Consistency:

Simulation
Programming:
Accuracy:
Educational value:
Innovation:

Vote for one and/or rate each out of 10 and I'll update the polls on this post!

Last edited by Flait7 (2012-01-17 15:59:09)

rabbit1131 · 2012-01-17 14:26:02

Programming: 10
Graphics: 8
Replay value: 3
Memorability: 9
Audio: 7
Storyline: 10
Animation: 8
Difficulty (easy): 6
Difficulty (hard): 6
Playability: 10

cheddargirl · 2012-01-17 14:32:15

Not to be nit-picky, but it seems like the above criteria is geared mostly at games and animations. What about things that fall outside that genre, like simulations?

CheeseMunchy · 2012-01-17 14:36:03

Programming: 10
Graphics: 8
Replay value: 10
Memorability: 8
Audio: 5
Storyline: 3
Animation: 2
Difficulty (easy): 5
Difficulty (hard): 5
Playability: 8

Flait7 · 2012-01-17 14:36:52

Well, what other criteria could I add for animations and simulations? I'll be happy to add them in.

CheeseMunchy · 2012-01-17 14:40:26

Flait7 wrote:
Well, what other criteria could I add for animations and simulations? I'll be happy to add them in.

Physics?
Mathematics?

Flait7 · 2012-01-17 14:41:22

That would be a part of the programming imo.

Flait7 · 2012-01-17 14:52:50

Like say, by "playable" I mean the controls of the game. Whether the game's easy to play and understand, like super mario brothers, or tetris; they'd be easily playable. Or if the controls are a bit more awkward and difficult (like turok 2, or south park 64 in my oppinion, idk if anyone agrees).

RedRocker227 · 2012-01-17 15:00:05

Oh, okay. In that case, I think playability is the most important smile

rabbit1131 · 2012-01-17 15:02:58

RedRocker227 wrote:
Oh, okay. In that case, I think playability is the most important

I think programming is more so, because good controls, but glitchy isn't very good.

RedRocker227 · 2012-01-17 15:06:33

rabbit1131 wrote:
RedRocker227 wrote:
Oh, okay. In that case, I think playability is the most important
I think programming is more so, because good controls, but glitchy isn't very good.

You've got point actually! Okay, playability and programming are tied then tongue

NeilWest · 2012-01-17 15:07:34

Programming: 9
Graphics: 5
Replay value: 8
Memorability: 10
Audio: 8
Storyline: 7
Animation: 6
Difficulty (easy): 8
Difficulty (hard): 8
Playability: 10

These are my thoughts. smile

Targethero · 2012-01-17 15:08:26

Flait7 wrote:
Programming: 8
Graphics: 9
Replay value:10
Memorability:10
Audio:7
Storyline:8
Animation:6
Difficulty (easy):8
Difficulty (hard):6
Playability:10

Last edited by Targethero (2012-01-17 15:08:55)

fungirl123 · 2012-01-17 15:09:12

I would think that programming is the most important.

cheddargirl · 2012-01-17 15:23:47

Flait7 wrote:
Well, what other criteria could I add for animations and simulations? I'll be happy to add them in.

Actually, my nit-pickyness is more about making the categories inclusive for all types of projects. For example, a simulation doesn't usually require a storyline at all; so if were to base our criteria on simulations, storyline might be considered a zero, but in comparison to games and animation, storyline can be pretty important.

Maybe you might want to replace "Storyline" with "innovation"? Basically, how original is the idea behind the project. I think that's more inclusive to all types of projects.

Also, maybe instead of "playability", "control" might be a better word. You don't necessarily play all projects, but most project do require some degree of control (for example, in consideration of something like a tutorial projects, some of the best ones are those that allow a user to control the pace at which the tutorial runs).

DisasterMaster · 2012-01-17 15:46:46

Programming: 10
Graphics: 3
Replay value: 8
Memorability: 6
Audio: 2
Storyline: 5
Animation: 5
Difficulty (easy): 7
Difficulty (hard): 7
Playability: 10

Zeusking19 · 2012-01-17 15:48:51

Usability would be a better word.

Flait7 · 2012-01-17 15:53:35

Okay, I'll re-organize it.

rontoking · 2012-01-27 14:41:33

Programming:8
Graphics:7
Replay value:6
Memorability:4
Audio:4
Storyline:5
Animation:6
Difficulty (easy):4
Difficulty (hard):7
Controls:6
Originality:7

Last edited by rontoking (2012-01-28 12:15:35)

RedRocker227 · 2012-01-27 14:50:04

rontoking wrote:
can you rate this?
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/rontoking/2059469

Um... this isn't a "rate my project" thread, you know ._.

Scratch

archived forums

#1 2012-01-17 14:17:05

Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#2 2012-01-17 14:26:02

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#3 2012-01-17 14:32:15

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#4 2012-01-17 14:36:03

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#5 2012-01-17 14:36:52

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#6 2012-01-17 14:40:26

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

Flait7 wrote:

#7 2012-01-17 14:41:22

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#8 2012-01-17 14:52:50

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#9 2012-01-17 15:00:05

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#10 2012-01-17 15:02:58

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

RedRocker227 wrote:

#11 2012-01-17 15:06:33

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

rabbit1131 wrote:

RedRocker227 wrote:

#12 2012-01-17 15:07:34

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#13 2012-01-17 15:08:26

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

Flait7 wrote:

#14 2012-01-17 15:09:12

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#15 2012-01-17 15:23:47

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

Flait7 wrote:

#16 2012-01-17 15:46:46

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#17 2012-01-17 15:48:51

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#18 2012-01-17 15:53:35

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#19 2012-01-27 14:41:33

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

#20 2012-01-27 14:50:04

Re: Poll: What do you think is the most important in a Scratch project?

rontoking wrote:

Board footer