Scratch

TheBlueRocky wrote:

randomnumber53's Game

Creativity-
5
Game Concept-
6
Originality-
6
Art-
5
Programming-
9
Total-
31

Final Review:
21-40: You can do better.

In case you missed it because I created a new page in a post. X0

randomnumber53 wrote:

TheBlueRocky wrote:

TheBlueRocky wrote:

randomnumber53's Game

Creativity-
5
Game Concept-
6
Originality-
6
Art-
5
Programming-
9
Total-
31

Final Review:
21-40: You can do better.

In case you missed it because I created a new page in a post. X0

Wait, so why did I get marked down?

???

I posted it twice because after I posted it the first time, I made another post, creating a new page, so I wasn't sure you'd check the previous page to find it.

randomnumber53 wrote:

TheBlueRocky wrote:

randomnumber53 wrote:

Wait, so why did I get marked down?

???

I posted it twice because after I posted it the first time, I made another post, creating a new page, so I wasn't sure you'd check the previous page to find it.

No, I mean why did my game get a bad review?

I'm not giving reasoning to my reviews as they create flame wars. Sorry.

pokemongardevoir wrote:

I don't mean to irritate you or anything, but your reviews are so well organized, can I have some tips? How can I take steps to give my own projects a fair review, without being too biased? I really want to give myself a review (Considering most reviewers such as yourself don't do dressups/creators) so I can improve what needs to be inproved and feel proud of myself for what's exceptional, and then find ways to make the amazing even better!

Here's what I do:

For programming, I look at the physics. Are they buggy? Are they unrealistic? Do they work well?

For game concept, this is the trickiest. It's whatever you like best. Are you happy with your game? Is it not your best?

For art, think about the time and effort you spent on it. Did you just get them from the internet? Did you hire someone else? How long you spend on them? Did you rush them?

For originality, compare it to Nintendo, Scratch, Sega, Microsoft, Valve, or even Mojang games. Are there any games similar to yours? How much time you did you spend on the game idea? Did you base your game on another one? Does it have characters or features from published games (Mario, Sonic, Minecraft, etc.)?

For creativity, this might be a little hard. Think about your game characters, storyline, gameplay, and concept. Is it a platformer (not very creative - done too much)? Is the gameplay unique/addicting? Is this a popular game concept (not very creative - didn't think of it yourself)?

Don't create the final review first. It'll end up biased and off-balanced. Do the categories and total it to get the result, and it'll come out more honest. 

can you rate my game?

wait- can it be a remix?

does it have to be a game?

all it has is words

sportsdude6 wrote:

all it has is words

*facepalm*

GAME ratings.

TheBlueRocky wrote:

sportsdude6 wrote:

all it has is words

*facepalm*

GAME ratings.

For when one facepalm isn't enough:
*double-facepalm*

And I'm guessing Stone Age will get around an 80.

Death_Wish wrote:

TheBlueRocky wrote:

sportsdude6 wrote:

all it has is words

*facepalm*

GAME ratings.

For when one facepalm isn't enough:
*double-facepalm*

And I'm guessing Stone Age will get around an 80.

Probably, it deserves it. I'll do it now.

Hotwire's Game

Creativity-
17
Game Concept-
19
Originality-
11
Art-
20
Programming-
20
Total-
87

Final Review:
81-100: Excellent! I love it.

Sounds about right! 

Thanks!