Scratch

Wow! An app? Cool!

What do you think of my Warrior Maker, Office Designer, and/or Me! Maker?

Please choose your favorite(s) to review 

Last edited by pokemongardevoir (2011-08-22 19:08:43)

TheBlueRocky wrote:

I don't really find dress-ups or designers as games.

Oh... ok.... :c

But can you please rate one of them?

Last edited by pokemongardevoir (2011-08-22 19:21:05)

TheBlueRocky wrote:

Sorry, I'm only doing game ratings.

Alright. Hey, when my collab camp is finished, would you rate that?

4lover's Game

Creativity-
10
Game Concept-
6
Originality-
2
Art-
3
Programming-
7
Total-
28

Final Review:
21-40: You can do better.

Last edited by TheBlueRocky (2011-08-22 19:48:30)

Review my game?

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Death_Wish/1944846
I'm guessing a... 30-40 (It's not that good, I'm going to try to make it better someday  )

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/jcf2837/1990603
My latest game.

Rate this one: http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Thescratch3/1977742

TheBlueRocky wrote:

jcf2837 wrote:

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/jcf2837/1990603
My latest game.

I'm not rating a stolen game.

What's the difference between your remix and the original?

Did you even bother to look at the original? It's a sprite pack. I just used the sprites and built the game from the same file.

jcf2837 wrote:

TheBlueRocky wrote:

jcf2837 wrote:

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/jcf2837/1990603
My latest game.

I'm not rating a stolen game.

What's the difference between your remix and the original?

Did you even bother to look at the original? It's a sprite pack. I just used the sprites and built the game from the same file.

Okay sorry, I was sure I saw somewhere else...whatever. I must have had deja vu. Once again, sorry.

jcf2837's Game

Creativity-
4
Game Concept-
6
Originality-
12
Art-
3
Programming-
18
Total-
43

Final Review:
41-60: It's OK, just needs some improvements.

TheBlueRocky wrote:

Thescratch3 wrote:

TheBlueRocky wrote:

Thescratch3's Game

Creativity-
6
Game Concept-
4
Originality-
2
Art-
8
Programming-
10
Total-
30

Final Review:
21-40: You can do better.

. Well at least it got top loved. But really I think my game is close to 70.

I disagree.

It's a very simple platformer (scrolling does not make it special) with no special features, simple art, and programming that allows you to walk inside the platforms.

Well every single comment on that said either nice, awesome, or something saying they liked the game. You should also take notice of comments, they also tell about the project. Well I don't really care about the rating, I am just happy it is top loved.

Thescratch3 wrote:

TheBlueRocky wrote:

Thescratch3 wrote:

. Well at least it got top loved. But really I think my game is close to 70.

I disagree.

It's a very simple platformer (scrolling does not make it special) with no special features, simple art, and programming that allows you to walk inside the platforms.

Well every single comment on that said either nice, awesome, or something saying they liked the game. You should also take notice of comments, they also tell about the project. Well I don't really care about the rating, I am just happy it is top loved.

If you don't like ratings, why did you come here?

The Scratch community will go nuts for any platformer. I honestly cannot stand platformers.

Ever played on Nitrome.com? Nitrome is an example of perfect Scratch games. Scratch is capable of such games, but no one uses it it's full potenital. It's wasted on animations, remixes, and art trades. I believe your game is a step 2 towards games like Nitrome's.