Scratch

The books.

Only people who haven't read the books would say movies 

Books

Books, although they did a great job of turning the HP books into movies, unlike other books. (coughERAGONcough)

The movies are good, but the books are better.

Books!! But the films are still really good! XD

Book

TimeFreeze wrote:

I disiliked films 4, 5, 6, and 8.

8 was ALL for money. They knew that they would have to make 7 as good as possible in order to reel in people to watch 8. They didn't put in, like any effort but they did get a lot of money 

I disagree. I disliked films 1 and 2, but for the most part liked the rest (3 was the best). 8 *wasn't* just for the money, and they actually churned out a fantastic movie, with 97% of critics liking it. Compare that to 95% for The King's Speech.

In the order in which I like the movies, I'd have to say 3, 8, 6/7 (they're tied for me), 5, 4, 1, 2.

It pains me to say it, but I like them both (books and movies) equally. Books and movies are two completely different formats, and if you're trying to compare them, you're missing the point entirely.

coolstuff wrote:

TimeFreeze wrote:

I disiliked films 4, 5, 6, and 8.

8 was ALL for money. They knew that they would have to make 7 as good as possible in order to reel in people to watch 8. They didn't put in, like any effort but they did get a lot of money 

I disagree. I disliked films 1 and 2, but for the most part liked the rest (3 was the best). 8 *wasn't* just for the money, and they actually churned out a fantastic movie, with 97% of critics liking it. Compare that to 95% for The King's Speech.

In the order in which I like the movies, I'd have to say 3, 8, 6/7 (they're tied for me), 5, 4, 1, 2.

It pains me to say it, but I like them both (books and movies) equally. Books and movies are two completely different formats, and if you're trying to compare them, you're missing the point entirely.

I don't know, I feel like they barely stuck to the book on 8. They missed a bunch of parts in 4. I am a bit on both sides for 5 and 6, I thought 7 was really good, and I do agree with you that 3 was the best.

Wickimen wrote:

I'd have to say books!    They're so good I can't decide which I like the most. The movies are okay, but I can definitely tell you which ones I like the best, in this order, (best to worst). 3, 1 and 2, 7 and 8, 5 and 6 and 4. I don't know, 4 wasn't very well done and 5 wasn't either, and I hate to say 6 as the very dead last. 6 was all right, just a major disappointment to me because the preview was so good and 6 was so... not very good.

This has nothing to do with that, but why bother putting one of the online/offline things in your sig when people can just look at the side of your post and it tells them.

Both

________________________

johndo77 wrote:

Books. My favorite is the 7th OF COURSE.

Meh, I'm more a "prisinor of azkaban" person me myself!

Wickimen wrote:

frizzlepuss893 wrote:

Wickimen wrote:

I'd have to say books!    They're so good I can't decide which I like the most. The movies are okay, but I can definitely tell you which ones I like the best, in this order, (best to worst). 3, 1 and 2, 7 and 8, 5 and 6 and 4. I don't know, 4 wasn't very well done and 5 wasn't either, and I hate to say 6 as the very dead last. 6 was all right, just a major disappointment to me because the preview was so good and 6 was so... not very good.

This has nothing to do with that, but why bother putting one of the online/offline things in your sig when people can just look at the side of your post and it tells them.

I've been on here a lot longer than you, don't you think I've noticed? I just like them, and the green catches your eye more than Online.

i agree.