Scratch

Why is there so much debating about this? This isn't a competition........

....because Harry Potter wins no matter what, after all 

soupoftomato wrote:

SuperYoshiluver13 wrote:

soupoftomato wrote:

She's voted president of the world for not reading Twilight?

You are confusing one.

She speaks wisdom that is the hardcore truth!!!

It's still fun to discuss.

true!

cheddargirl wrote:

soupoftomato wrote:

Put it all here I guess since we've been driven out of the thread we were using and I like debating this. 

So which is better and why?

I think it depends on what the user is interested in. ^^

You know I'd like to see someone who is both a Harry Potter and Twilight fan to give his/her point of view. Less bias ftw. 

Your wish is answered.

I am a fan of Harry Potter and Twilight, and let's face it, it's the old LOTR/Star Wars comparison again. You simply cannot measure a fantasy wizard story against a romance vampire story. Same as you cannot measure epic classical fantasy against epic classical science fiction.

Also, I am a fan of LOTR and Star Wars as well. All are well written.

Harry potter, nothing will never top it.

SuperYoshiluver13 wrote:

lilacfuzz101 wrote:

  Really people. You won't convince someone that your book is better than theirs. True fans will stay fans no matter what others say. I, for one, have not and will not read either.

I VOTE FOR YOU FOR PRESIDENT OF THE WORLD!!! 

I honestly didn't think that anyone was gonna agree with me    Thanks I guess.

imnotbob wrote:

Harakou wrote:

fire219 wrote:

Harry Potter wins. Twilight is just stupid. Seriously, sparkling vampires? What kind of vampire sparkles? Vampires are supposed to be evil creatures, not weak creatures that are made out of sequins and glitter. 

I don't like Twilight either, but maybe it would be better to discuss the actual plot, writing or characters rather than the fact that you don't like the premise. 

FICTION

Even most fiction doesn't break multiple laws of science.

soupoftomato wrote:

imnotbob wrote:

Harakou wrote:

I don't like Twilight either, but maybe it would be better to discuss the actual plot, writing or characters rather than the fact that you don't like the premise. 

FICTION

Even most fiction doesn't break multiple laws of science.

magic isnt real. unicorns arent real.

brettman98 wrote:

imnotbob wrote:

soupoftomato wrote:

Even most fiction doesn't break multiple laws of science.

magic isnt real. unicorns arent real.

says you; how do you know that magic isn't real? (Not implying it is real, not implying it isn't)

magic TRICKS are, if u take into account that theyre tricks.
there's no such thing as REAL magic.

imnotbob wrote:

brettman98 wrote:

imnotbob wrote:

magic isnt real. unicorns arent real.

says you; how do you know that magic isn't real? (Not implying it is real, not implying it isn't)

magic TRICKS are, if u take into account that theyre tricks.
there's no such thing as REAL magic.

Magic tricks aren't even CLOSE to the real magic tho. Harry Potter and Twilight just have graphic effects! Yes, the magic of the greenscreen and some editing can make a movie brilliant but not real! (agreeing with Imnotbob)

GravityCatisalie wrote:

Wickimen wrote:

brettman98 wrote:

I didn't know earwax made you a Twilight fan 

The earwax-flavored Bertie Botts' Bean 

I once ate a puke flavored one D:

Ikr! I ate 2 vomits(they were very tasty), 1 earwax(it tastes nothing like real earwax:lol:), 1 rotten egg(it was gross), 1 soap(yummy), 3 cinnamons(they taste weird). I even ate real grass(off of the ground).    My cousin offered me a bag to spit the jelly beans out, but I swallowed every one of them(except the real grass).

brettman98 wrote:

imnotbob wrote:

soupoftomato wrote:

Even most fiction doesn't break multiple laws of science.

magic isnt real. unicorns arent real.

says you; how do you know that magic isn't real? (Not implying it is real, not implying it isn't)

I'm a sparkling Lord Voldedward. Magic is real - to sparkling evil villians. lol

pokeywokey wrote:

GravityCatisalie wrote:

Wickimen wrote:

The earwax-flavored Bertie Botts' Bean 

I once ate a puke flavored one D:

Ikr! I ate 2 vomits(they were very tasty), 1 earwax(it tastes nothing like real earwax:lol:), 1 rotten egg(it was gross), 1 soap(yummy), 3 cinnamons(they taste weird). I even ate real grass(off of the ground).    My cousin offered me a bag to spit the jelly beans out, but I swallowed every one of them(except the real grass).

I love the grass flavour, it's amazing 

SuperYoshiluver13 wrote:

The closest thing to magic here (on Earth) is cartoons, science, and magic tricks.

Any proof? The average human implies just because they haven't seen something, it doesn't exist. The truth is, that is a total contradiction. If you haven't seen something, it means you have no right to say it doesn't exist.