In the school where I work all the PC's are configured so when the kids save a file they can only access their personal directory on a file server somewhere. Since Scratch uses it's own file save dialog this restriction is bypassed, they can surf the whole school network. I guess all they can really do is save a file in an improper place but this gives the lady in charge of the network the heebie-jeebies and keeps me from being able to allow the kids to use Scratch (I did show it to them). It would be nice if there was a switch in the .ini file that allowed you to restrict where they can save a file to the share they loaded Scratch from or maybe the directory where the demo projects are.
I suspect this problem exists in many schools
Thanks for the kool app
Dave
Last edited by bosco1 (2008-10-21 19:19:04)
Offline
Hi Dave,
you can specify in the .ini file which drives you want to be visible for the kids in your school network. Check out the technical appendix on page 20 of the Scratch reference guide in the support section. I hope this solves your problem.
Another way to let your students use Scratch in a locked down school network is to allow them to start it locally from their own flash drives. Instead of downloading and installing the ScratchInstaller you can just download the "files-only" version, unzip it to a portable drive and start Scratch directly from there. That way, if the network is really secure (and not just obscured) students can save their projects only to their portable devices.
I really hope you can work out something with your network administrator, so that your students will be able to use Scratch in school!
Offline
> I suspect this problem exists in many schools
I can name a couple of hundred in my vicinity. Sorry folks but relatively common Windows domain lockdown doesn't like or clashes badly with:
-- D-I-Y file open/save dialogs that bypass the policy you've set for the Windows one.
-- Option to save things somewhere under the Program Files\<appname> especially on a multi-user machine.
-- Option to save things on the desktop.
-- Running apps from pensticks.
Most of the MS "logo compliance" rules for these kind of things turned up almost a decade ago and there were *very* good reasons for them. I definitely don't like criticising free-lunches, but I can't see any credible way to deploy this on a typical school system unless I can explicitly say a) where the user can save & subsequently open projects/resources, b) where samples projects et al can be loaded from. Hiding drives isn't enough.
Offline
Maybe the next version of Scratch should use a native file browsing window.
I have Scratch for OS X, and I am able to see many weird things on my hard drive.
For example, there are two external hard drives connected to my iMac, one called "Media", and one called "Time Machine Backups", here is what I see in the scratch window.
- Macintosh HD
- Media
- Media 2
- Media 3
- Media 8
- Time Machine Backups
I'm not sure where the extra 3 Media drives came from..... I can only see them in the Scratch file browser.
Offline