Scratch

Harley, your project's better
My vote goes to you

Last edited by Blade-Edge (2011-02-08 07:28:38)

HarleyK for sure!

+1 to harley

I liked both projects quite a bit, so I'll give my own critiques of each and write what I liked or didn't like about each.

HarleyK- 128 provided good graphics and special effects for a one sprite one script game.  Its combination of fast-paced timing and slow thoughtful puzzle solving proved pretty interesting.  Unique gameplay made this project stand out.  Its simplicity is what kept it addicting.

goalkeepery- Scratch sticks provided diverse instances of gameplay that kept you on your toes for each level.  While the graphics could have been made better for a project with multiple sprites and scripts, some graphics had some polish to it.  Overall it had an interesting style of play with a rather, well, different kind of storyline.

Final verdict- HarleyK
This game was very good for a one sprite one script game, and its original combination of fast and slow kept it very interesting.  Scratch sticks had more variety but overall fell slightly short on keeping things lively and addictive.

I'd like to conclude by saying that I did not dislike Scratch Sticks, it's just I have to pick a winner and made a decision on which I thought was more fun.  I hope the both of you make more projects of the same or better quality in the future.

HarleyK wrote:

6-1

Lol I'm doing great (sarcastic)

sorry goalkeeper, but im gonna give this vote to harley, i liked both games, but harleys was really addictive

goalkeepery wrote:

HarleyK wrote:

6-1

Lol I'm doing great (sarcastic)

no 8-1 i vote for harlyK i have played one of harlyKs games and it was great thats space ball and the one i vote for

Last edited by dudymate (2011-04-12 14:09:22)

goalkeepery

Hmmm.. both games were really awesome, but I have to vote for HarleyK.

goal-keeper definitely. harley-whateverisrighthere. your game's just way too hard

HarleyK wrote:

11-4

is'nt it 12-3