Scratch

Telemachus wrote:

Give them some time 
I can release the 2nd challenge early if people want that....

oh please!

Go ahead.

Anyways, I'm hoping to get the judging and the next contest underway today. 

Last edited by Telemachus (2010-08-22 10:05:43)

antimonyarsenide wrote:

platform710:
Originality-3/3 (First entry with an idea using rotation sensing)
Creativity-4/5 (See above. Polar coordinate systems are fun and creative to use    )
Skill-2/5 (Uses early intermediate broadcast and timer set scripts, but nothing hard to code)
Clarity-0/1 (Useless but active color-based script, 2 stray blocks, uses variable to set something that never changes anyway [the 0,0 position])
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
1 point for small sensor

Total: 11 points

roger-:
Originality-2/3 (AB3 came up with the long "if" chain idea, but most factors are original)
Creativity-4/5 (The sensor+returning variable method is pretty creative    )
Skill-4/5 (Using if-else chains and making it one frame is a show of respectable skill)
Clarity-1/1 (a few stray blocks, and a few non-optimal block placings, but no major useless stuff)
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
1 point for small sensor

Total: 13 points

AtomicBawm3:
Originality-3/3 (First person to use long if chains to reduce frames  )
Creativity-3/5 (Somewhat creative if-chaining strategy, but it's basically just conditions and basic movement)
Skill-3/5 (making it one frame is skillful, but there's not THAT much knowledge needed for the scripting)
Clarity-1/1 (Nothing useless  )
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point
No sensor: 3 points

Total: 14 points

acester:
Originality: 2/3 (rotating sensing has already been used, but the way you're doing it with a radar sensor is pretty original, I guess.)
Creativity: 3/5 (See above.)
Skill: 2/5 (The trig is not very useful, unfortunately. Lots of repeat blocks and other aspects of your scripts show that your programming skill is pretty average.)
Clarity: 0/1 (using operation blocks for basic constant math, two motion blocks to do one movement, and more not-so-efficient scripts.)
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
1 point for small sensor
3 points for trig use.
Total: 12 points
I'm not entirely sure the trig counts as constructive. Telemachus should help verify this.

Sorry, I have to go now but I'll grade the other two when I get back 

chipguy:
Originality: 3/3 (Color sensor!  )
Creativity: 4.5/5 (See above    Not perfectly creative, but quite close.)
Skill: 3/5 (Decent skill with color sensing)
Clarity: 1/1
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
Goto block: -2 points

Total: 10.5 points

recycle49:
Originality: 3/3 (Sensorless rotation  )
Creativity: 3/5 (Not extremely creative, but decent)
Skill: 3/5 (You got the angle coverage well done, but it uses repeat blocks    )
Clarity: 0.5 (Stuff on the stage, but that's minor.)
Bonus:
No sensor: 3 points

Total: 12.5 points

...And I'm done with the judging! 

TeleContest wrote:

antimonyarsenide wrote:

antimonyarsenide wrote:

platform710:
Originality-3/3 (First entry with an idea using rotation sensing)
Creativity-4/5 (See above. Polar coordinate systems are fun and creative to use    )
Skill-2/5 (Uses early intermediate broadcast and timer set scripts, but nothing hard to code)
Clarity-0/1 (Useless but active color-based script, 2 stray blocks, uses variable to set something that never changes anyway [the 0,0 position])
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
1 point for small sensor

Total: 11 points

roger-:
Originality-2/3 (AB3 came up with the long "if" chain idea, but most factors are original)
Creativity-4/5 (The sensor+returning variable method is pretty creative    )
Skill-4/5 (Using if-else chains and making it one frame is a show of respectable skill)
Clarity-1/1 (a few stray blocks, and a few non-optimal block placings, but no major useless stuff)
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
1 point for small sensor

Total: 13 points

AtomicBawm3:
Originality-3/3 (First person to use long if chains to reduce frames  )
Creativity-3/5 (Somewhat creative if-chaining strategy, but it's basically just conditions and basic movement)
Skill-3/5 (making it one frame is skillful, but there's not THAT much knowledge needed for the scripting)
Clarity-1/1 (Nothing useless  )
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point
No sensor: 3 points

Total: 14 points

acester:
Originality: 2/3 (rotating sensing has already been used, but the way you're doing it with a radar sensor is pretty original, I guess.)
Creativity: 3/5 (See above.)
Skill: 2/5 (The trig is not very useful, unfortunately. Lots of repeat blocks and other aspects of your scripts show that your programming skill is pretty average.)
Clarity: 0/1 (using operation blocks for basic constant math, two motion blocks to do one movement, and more not-so-efficient scripts.)
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
1 point for small sensor
3 points for trig use.
Total: 12 points
I'm not entirely sure the trig counts as constructive. Telemachus should help verify this.

Sorry, I have to go now but I'll grade the other two when I get back 

chipguy:
Originality: 3/3 (Color sensor!  )
Creativity: 4.5/5 (See above    Not perfectly creative, but quite close.)
Skill: 3/5 (Decent skill with color sensing)
Clarity: 1/1
Bonus:
No go to x,y block: 1 point (beginning positioning doesn't count  )
Goto block: -2 points

Total: 10.5 points

recycle49:
Originality: 3/3 (Sensorless rotation  )
Creativity: 3/5 (Not extremely creative, but decent)
Skill: 3/5 (You got the angle coverage well done, but it uses repeat blocks    )
Clarity: 0.5 (Stuff on the stage, but that's minor.)
Bonus:
No sensor: 3 points

Total: 12.5 points

...And I'm done with the judging! 

Nice! Only 2 more submissions needed 

do you mean judgeing submissions or proggramming sumbitions?


can i make another thing just for the fun of it?

turtlewarrior wrote:

Ugh, I'm sorry I can't vote for this contest.

Why?

uh... you have to update this. JeanTheFox isn't a judge anymore...
and neither is turtlewarrior...

Last edited by roger- (2010-08-23 20:26:18)

Is the challenge coming soon?

I would be judge.... if I wasn't a contestant.

Definitely. I may even get it out tonight.

(cough cough)

*Gag gag*