Scratch

I don't think this is fair because the people on the list have all had their games on the homepage, but anyone could have an absolutely fantastic game but nobody knows about it, so i think there should be a competition to see who should be on the list of best scratchers.
Look at the little dudes dance!!!

coolstuff wrote:

piplupquaza wrote:

I don't think this is fair because the people on the list have all had their games on the homepage, but anyone could have an absolutely fantastic game but nobody knows about it, so i think there should be a competition to see who should be on the list of best scratchers.
http://www5d.biglobe.ne.jp/~aoi-k/scribble/scrib251.gif Look at the little dudes dance!!!

That is a good idea.

I agree that other unknows are good but it's impossible to find them. If you think anyone else should be on the list please tell me

Last edited by BestOnScratchContest (2008-05-31 15:52:28)

BestOnScratchContest wrote:

Because of all the negative input I dedcided to contact the Scratch team to ask them if they think I should continue with my expiriment or abort it.

That is a good idea.

BestOnScratchContest wrote:

Doesn't anyone think anyone else should be added

I do but I don't know who.

How about me! Not all my games are great but their ok. If I make a super cool scroller game could I possibly get in? 

no me im ok

There are many different ways of evaluating the work of people on Scratch. In many ways is like asking for a list of the best musicians. There are so many different types of music and styles, and there is people who like some and not others. Some people who don't like classical music might not like Mozart while others might think it's the greatest composer ever. Who is right? No one, and everyone. It's very subjective. For these and other reasons, contests like this one have not been well received by the Scratch Community.

I think is OK if you list the name of the Scratchers that you admire the most because that's your own opinion and it would be a good compliment for those people. One thing you could do, is always emphasize that it's just your own opinion and that other people might have different opinions.

On the other hand, I think a lot of the people on this forums already have their favorite Scratchers and that's what your list of favorite projects is for.

A good challenge would be to find unknown Scratchers that have never been on the front page whose work is really interesting!

If you search on the forums you might find similar threads that have lead to unnecessary arguments, so I would just like to ask you to keep this thread positive and constructive otherwise it can get closed.

Well, that's my opinion :-)

I'm not saying who I think is the best on scratch, I'm just trying to see who the people think is the best on scratch. I also am making a requirement that someone else has to post your name on the forums to be added to the list because everyone thinks they are good 

siddthesquid wrote:

i think that the majority of the people are against this idea... but srsly, this is pointlesss... wuts to gain from knowing who the best scratcher is? youll make one person happy, but upset all others.....every1 is good in theyre own way in scratch, and you cant really judge different things of this sort

I agree that everyone is good in thier own way. But I am not judging, I'm asking the people to vote on who they think is best. And wwhat is to gain from knowing who the most popular scratcher is. Use your brain for once in your life sidd. If you know who the most popular scratcher is then you know what the common scratch member enjoys in a project. Using this info you can become popular too.

I personally think that one major person is not on that list. I nominate fullmoon as one of the best scratchers on the website. I personally do not think that I would be good enough to be on here, so I will not ask    I do think that fullmoon is, considering his many amazing projects, such as Blizzards Run, and his Dynamic Resize. The majority of my projects are not games, which are the things that interest people the most. Almost all of my projects are demos, or things that involve watching instead of actively participating. This is the first language I have ever learned to program in, and I consider myself a beginner, though I hope that you accept my nomination of fullmoon as a person on your list. I fully agree with all the people who are on it now!

I didn't have any prior knowledge either!!!

Look at my cool new signiture

what about me??? -_-. I had a top loved project! Yoshi's SCRATCHED Story!!! Plus, Tanner FBI doesn't even know how to make a scroller. Ok, fine, you don't have to add me...-_-...