Harry Potter was unique, and has started the modern rage for fantasy.
While the author of Twilight, picked a time of day, two monsters, through a monotonous girl in the mix and called it a book.
Offline
I agree with the tomato soup guy. Harry Potter is a literary achievement, and a great contribution to the world of fantasy books. In other words, I LOVE YOU, HARRY POTTER!

Offline
Artemis Fowl > Harry Potter > Lord of the Rings > Twilight in my opinion. The Lord of the Rings wasn't necessarily a bad book, but it was a boring and slow read, and that's sometimes more important than the story.
Offline
well, I'm reading harry potter and I'm a fanatic so... hmm... HARRY POTTER IS AWESOME!!!!! I would read harry potter over twilight any day! But twilight is ok... kind of boring, from my perspective!
Offline
fireball123 wrote:
Harry Potter > Barney > Twilight
Lol! I think harry potter is better because it actually shows! Twilight just drones on and on *snore* but harry potter's books actually use discriptive language! That means it uses words that actually discibe! In this case, Twilight doesn't! So, logically, you are correct! I would watch barney over twilight movies! Wouldn't you, everyone?????
Offline
J0j2 wrote:
I rather the Hunger games.
![]()
I bow down to you, great sir.
I hate Twilight, but have lost interest in Harry Potter.
I'll still see the next HP, though XD
Oh, and
webgal15 wrote:
Neither. I prefer Warriors.
Go grab a copy of The Hunger Games, sit in a corner, read it, and think about what you've done. Trust me, after reading that book, you'll be begging to sell your Warriors books.
Last edited by GirWaffles64 (2010-03-03 18:11:13)
Offline
GirWaffles64 wrote:
I'll still see the next HP, though XD
Part 1 comes out in November!
Harry potter is better than twilight. I have read all of the HPs, none of the TLs, but still think that HP is better. good books, good movies (exept for the 6th), and good video games.
Offline
guys can you please state why you like Harry Potter better? I doubt many of you have actually read Twilight, and are only saying it is bad because that's what everyone else thinks.

Offline
Kileymeister wrote:
Here we go: ( > = "is greater than")
AVATAR movie > 2012 (movie) > Harry Potter > 2012 (END OF THE WORLD) > Twilight.
That should tell you what I think.
...And I think so too.
Offline
VolknerN7Xfish wrote:
Iv'e heard my mom talk about twilight,and it is about an apple and some wierd snake.
harry potter makes WAY more sense than twilight.
A book about an apple and a weird snake is indeed a good one
Offline
TimeFreeze wrote:
Dude, Volkner, ur 8. I don't think that you understand most of the stuff in Twilight.
Just get a few girls on this topic, and we will get a barrage of annoying "Twilight is awesome" junk.
And ScratchX, you would be surprised to see how much 11/12 year olds know these days about that stuff..
Oh, Please. i'm a girl,and I think twilight is extreamly and utterly STUPID! I HAVE READ EACH AND EVERY HARRY POTTER BOOK OVER 20 TIMES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! QUIZ ME IF YOU WANNA!!!!!!!!!!! >

Offline
webgal15 wrote:
Neither. I prefer Warriors.
w00t! warrior cats forever!

Offline
funkymonkey wrote:
guys can you please state why you like Harry Potter better? I doubt many of you have actually read Twilight, and are only saying it is bad because that's what everyone else thinks.
I have read twilight, h8ed it,grabbed my harry potters and read them for the 20th time.

Offline
Star_the_fox wrote:
TimeFreeze wrote:
Dude, Volkner, ur 8. I don't think that you understand most of the stuff in Twilight.
Just get a few girls on this topic, and we will get a barrage of annoying "Twilight is awesome" junk.
And ScratchX, you would be surprised to see how much 11/12 year olds know these days about that stuff..Oh, Please. i'm a girl,and I think twilight is extreamly and utterly STUPID! I HAVE READ EACH AND EVERY HARRY POTTER BOOK OVER 20 TIMES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! QUIZ ME IF YOU WANNA!!!!!!!!!!! >
![]()
1) What does Ginny give Harry for his 17th birthday?
2) Where does Harry find Gryffindor's sword?
3) How old was Luna Lovegood when her mother died?
4) Who dies 19 years later after the 7th book?
5) When are Lily and James killed?
6) Who is Marjorie Dursley's right hand man?
7) Where was Sturgis Podmore caught?
8) What spell blasts off George's ear?
9) What's the name of Bill Weasley's daughter?
10) What's Molly Weasley's maiden name?
Try answering those.
Offline
funkymonkey wrote:
guys can you please state why you like Harry Potter better? I doubt many of you have actually read Twilight, and are only saying it is bad because that's what everyone else thinks.
I totally have a reason to say Harry Potter's better, because I read both and am a FORMER Twilight fan. I read Harry Potter first, and to this day its the greatest book ever written. Well, The Hunger Games, Percy Jackson, Warrior Cats, and any book by Stephen King are all my favorites too. I have reasons to like them all. Twilight is a sloppy romance that doesn't teach you anything, it ruined the vampire image. I think a series I just started reading called Cirque du Freak is a great vampire book, about REAL vampires. So is Dracula.
HARRY POTTER IS STILL THE BEST BOOK EVEH!

Offline
floatingmagictree wrote:
Star_the_fox wrote:
TimeFreeze wrote:
Dude, Volkner, ur 8. I don't think that you understand most of the stuff in Twilight.
Just get a few girls on this topic, and we will get a barrage of annoying "Twilight is awesome" junk.
And ScratchX, you would be surprised to see how much 11/12 year olds know these days about that stuff..Oh, Please. i'm a girl,and I think twilight is extreamly and utterly STUPID! I HAVE READ EACH AND EVERY HARRY POTTER BOOK OVER 20 TIMES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! QUIZ ME IF YOU WANNA!!!!!!!!!!! >
![]()
1) What does Ginny give Harry for his 17th birthday?
2) Where does Harry find Gryffindor's sword?
3) How old was Luna Lovegood when her mother died?
4) Who dies 19 years later after the 7th book?
5) When are Lily and James killed?
6) Who is Marjorie Dursley's right hand man?
7) Where was Sturgis Podmore caught?
8) What spell blasts off George's ear?
9) What's the name of Bill Weasley's daughter?
10) What's Molly Weasley's maiden name?
Try answering those.
Okay, I will:
1) Ginny gets Harry a kiss!
2) Harry finds the sword in the Sorting Hat
3) She was nine
4) I'm not sure who dies
5) Lily and James were killed on October 31, 1981
6) Uh... Colonel Fubster, I'm guessing?
7) He was caught in the Ministry of Magic
8) Sectumsempra
9) ???
10) Her maiden name is Prewett (her brothers were Gideon and Fabian)
I almost got dem all!

Offline