Pease update the leader board so I will be tied first!
Offline
Game review: Purple Dot
Art: 7/10
Woah! I'm loving the 3D effect and the way it seems to zoom in when the level appears! However I think the in-game graphics could be improved...
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 6/10
Pretty fun, there were some cool obstacles and the artwork made it better but I think I'm just bored of platformer games...
Originality: 4/10
Unless you are bonechill's test account, I think you used his/her idea and just changed the dot purple. I know you made everything different but the ideas stay the same...
Addictive? 7/10
It was fun, I'll give you that but although there were some cool obstacles and the 3D thing was just epic! At the end of the day it is just another platformer game... There were also some glitches which disappointed me a bit...
My personal opinion: 6/10
Ok, I want to get straight to the point. It is fun, it is cool but to me it's just like any other platformer game. Don't be downhearted though. I really did have fun playing it!
Total: 30/50
Title: Nice 3D platformer game!
Last edited by iaoumeur (2013-01-24 12:22:18)
Offline
I'm submitting a group, but do 2 today and 1 tomorrow.
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2908148
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/firedrake969_test/3043552
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2964997
Offline
firedrake969_test wrote:
I'm submitting a group, but do 2 today and 1 tomorrow.
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2908148
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/firedrake969_test/3043552
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2964997
Whoah! Ok I'll start working on them!
Offline
Game review: Jetpack Quest
Art: 6/10
I know the art wasn't yours but it matched the theme. I know you drew the levels and they were quite cool...
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 7/10
Yeah it is a platformer game, but with a twist! I really like the jetpack idea but there were a lot of glitches to do with the jetpack which prevented you from getting a higher score...
Originality: 5/10
I know there was a jetpack which made it quite different but the art wasn't yours and neither was the platformer base. I have also seen loads of platformer games and this is still kind of the same...
Addictive? 8/10
I liked it. The jetpack made it more fun and there was quite a few levels which kept me going for a while...
My personal opinion: 6/10
It was good. It was fun. But it wasn't amazing. It was a lot like many other platformer games but just with a jetpack. It was cool of course but I think you could have spent a little more time making it a bit more unique...
Total: 32/50
Title: Platformer with a jetpack sprite!
Offline
firedrake969_test wrote:
I'm submitting a group, but do 2 today and 1 tomorrow.
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2908148
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/firedrake969_test/3043552
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2964997
Sorry I can't review the last two because they aren't actually games, they are just bases or engines... Sorry...
Offline
Heres my game :-)
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/LiamHinsley/3057709
Offline
Game review: Infinty Flow VS Hyper perfect Nazo
Art: 5/10
Sorry becuase you didn't draw the sprites I have to give you a low score... But it still matched the theme which was great!
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 6/10
Kinda fun, there were a few options to attack or heal but I think you could have made it better by adding more attack options and magic power.
Originality: 5/10
I've seen these kind of battles before and there isn't much change. I feel you could have hanged it around to make it unique...
Addictive? 8/10
I don't know why I just really liked playing this! I just loved the special move!
My personal opinion: 7/10
This battle is a lot like any other battle game but it looks really nice and if you drew the sprites, then you deserve a special mention! Please tell me if you did draw them because I could update it.
Total: 31/50
Title: Fun sonic battle game!
Last edited by iaoumeur (2013-01-26 09:24:14)
Offline
Game review: My pet devil 0.2
Art: 5/10
I can see you drew the sprites, so that's a start but I feel there was more you could do with this...
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 3/10
Yeah it was fun at first but you can only change how the devil looks like. To make it more fun you should be able to interact with it, like give it food and let it cause havoc!
Originality: 5/10
This isn't original, I've seen many pet simulators. However you drew your sprites which means it ups your score a bit.
Addictive? 4/10
It was addictive at first but that only lasted a few seconds because there was nothing else to do!
My personal opinion: 6/10
I can see you're a new scratcher and this is your first project but I think you could have spent a bit more time making extras. However you drew all your sprites which many scratchers don't do so I congratulate you!
Total: 23/50
Title: Nice first project!
Offline
dsaztur wrote:
iaoumeur wrote:
dzaster wrote:
Thanks! will you improve the rating if I add updates?
Yes! Of course! Just post on here when you update it and I edit the first review. Good luck if you update it!
I'm making a sequel soon.
Cool! I can't wait to see it!
Offline
Here's my two projects, both use only my own artwork and programming:
Generation:3000
*This is better than the later version for it's tornadoes, fire and drive modes, research ability and 'evil' companies, but could only handle 97 tiles and was far more glitchy than the sequel-
Generation: 4013
*The engine used to create the simulator for the game was very complicated because nothing like that had ever been done before, it allowed the player to create 11025 tiled cities instead of small towns, and with over 50 objects and many features
Offline
Borrego6165 wrote:
Here's my two projects, both use only my own artwork and programming:
Generation:3000
*This is better than the later version for it's tornadoes, fire and drive modes, research ability and 'evil' companies, but could only handle 97 tiles and was far more glitchy than the sequel-
Generation: 4013
*The engine used to create the simulator for the game was very complicated because nothing like that had ever been done before, it allowed the player to create 11025 tiled cities instead of small towns, and with over 50 objects and many features
Ok thanks! I'm kind of busy with The Dot 2 but it's nearly finished and when it is I will review it straight away!
Sorry for the inconvenience...
Offline
iaoumeur wrote:
Borrego6165 wrote:
Here's my two projects, both use only my own artwork and programming:
Generation:3000
*This is better than the later version for it's tornadoes, fire and drive modes, research ability and 'evil' companies, but could only handle 97 tiles and was far more glitchy than the sequel-
Generation: 4013
*The engine used to create the simulator for the game was very complicated because nothing like that had ever been done before, it allowed the player to create 11025 tiled cities instead of small towns, and with over 50 objects and many featuresOk thanks! I'm kind of busy with The Dot 2 but it's nearly finished and when it is I will review it straight away!
Sorry for the inconvenience...
I meant UFO control not fires...
Offline
Game review: Scratch Cat detective
Art: 4/10
It was a bit basic for my taste. I know you can produce some excellent graphics so why not put them to use!
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 6/10
I like the scratch cat detective idea and the story seems to be the main thing. I just think it would be more fun if you made it look better...
Originality: 7/10
Never seen a detective game to do with the scratch cat so well done!
Addictive? 6/10
I wanted to earn these coins and see what they do. I'm afraid I can't give a higher score because it is just a demo...
My personal opinion: 6/10
I like this idea and I think it will be a great project when finished. I just think you could have improved the art and I know this is a demo but I have to say it- it needs more puzzles!
Total: 29/50
Title: Interesting detective game!
P.S: The Dot 2 is out if you want to see it...
Offline
Game review: Generation 3000
Art: 9/10
The art is REALLY good and there must have been so much to draw! You would have got a perfect 10 if I thought that the art was sensational!
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 10/10
I've only heard rumors about your games, I've never actually played them. The game is so fun with so much to do! You can drive a car and build a whole village! Amazing for a scratch game!
Originality: 10/10
I've never seen a game where you create a town that has so much detail and time put into it. Well done!
Addictive? 10/10
There was so much to do! You could build almost anything and I just wanted to get a town going. Great work!
My personal opinion: 10/10
Is there anything I need to say? This game truly lives up to it's title as one of the best games on scratch!
Total: 49/50
Title: One of the best games on scratch!
Offline
Game review: Generation 4013- Platinium
Art: 10/10
I think you definitely improved the art from last time. I loved the assistant (although he looked a bit like Pinocchio!) The building looked better than last time as well!
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 10/10
Again it was really fun. There were additions after last time which made it even more fun . It's a shame I can't give you an 11!
Originality: 10/10
Again I have never seen anything like this before so congratulations!
Addictive? 10/10
There was a lot more to do in Generation 4013 and I also think the assistant made it easier to play and was a better tutorial than the last one.
My personal opinion: 9/10
Although this game is TOTALLY epic somehow I think the layout of the other Generation game was better and bigger. Don't get me wrong though this game is definitely worthy of a special mention!
Total: 49/50
Title: Amazing sequel!
Offline
Woop woop! Shame my sequel technically didn't improve in score, maybe as an improvement you should do your reviews out of 100 as they may have been a more definite difference between the two. Still, thank-you!
Offline