Scratch

I'll go ahead and start you off with my Tanks series. Review all of them please, starting with the beginning, Tanks-1.

Last edited by sonicfan12p (2013-01-21 16:43:28)

Thanks

sonicfan12p wrote:

I'll go ahead and start you off with my Tanks series. Review all of them please, starting with the beginning, Tanks-1.

There are four games in the series and it's slow going to play through them all, just to say it will take a little while. Also, I'll probably rate the series as a whole rather than each episode separately. But they're very good so far, the sound and graphics (at least with what scratch offers) are great..

Last edited by bullelk12 (2013-01-21 19:38:17)

Borrego6165's project

...Wow, at long last, quality. Mine have never reached that level of quality.

Gameplay: 10/10  Incredible gameplay, it was very fun

Graphics: 10/10  Very, very good graphics

Goal: 10/10  Once again, fantastic. Games like this often don't have an end goal at all.

Originality: 9/10  The only reason it didn't get a ten is because there are many of them, I checked. But this one was by FAR the best one in existence.

Sound: 10/10  Great music, it fit the game to a "T"

Glitches: 10/10  Throughout the time I played I experienced non at all, so 10/10

Depth: 10/10  Your game scores 2nd highest on this aspect, it's off the charts in the amount of content in this game

Difficulty: 8/10  It wasn't as hard as it could have been. Even at the lowest amount of money it was just too easy

Addictiveness: 10/10  Your game scores highest on this aspect, because of the amount of content in this game it's very addictive

Overall: 15/15  I actually had to raise the bar on the overall aspect to 15 rather than ten just because of this game

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rating - 102/100      (this may seem odd but this game goes so far beyond the average limits of scratch it is literally off the charts, fantastic job Borrego6165

Last edited by bullelk12 (2013-01-23 02:54:48)

numberonegamers's project

All in all, very good, especially for one of those bloons type games.

Gameplay: 10/10  It was a very fun game all in all, it kept me from wanting to leave 

Graphics:  8/10  They could be a little better, especially the buttons. Other than that it was great

Goal: 8/10  There simply wasn't any goal but to survive, which is totally fine and does deserve an 8/10

Originality: 7/10  There are lots of these game as I'm sure you know, but this one was one of the better ones out there, good job

Sound: 10/10  It had good music that really did "suck" you in and kept me entertained while I killed badies. Fantastic music.

Glitches: 6/10  I did encounter a few big glitches that were kind of important, most important is that I had been doing great when all of a sudden the game just ended. It said I had -23 lives 

Depth: 8/10  Considering the number of cats that could be placed and upgraded you get an 8/10, though you could have gotten higher if you focused more on the enemies

Difficulty: 7/10  I played on hard and it wasn't that hard, rather methodical after 20 waves, just add more difficult enemies

Addictiveness: 9/10  Very good, most could play this game for a long time without stopping

Overall: 8/10  Put all the things together and it's a great game and deserves a lot of credit 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rating - 81/100

Last edited by bullelk12 (2013-01-23 02:56:42)

bullelk12 wrote:

numberonegamers's project

All in all, very good, especially for one of those bloons type games.

Gameplay: 10/10  It was a very fun game all in all, it kept me from wanting to leave 

Graphics:  8/10  They could be a little better, especially the buttons. Other than that it was great

Goal: 8/10  There simply wasn't any goal but to survive, which is totally fine and does deserve an 8/10

Originality: 7/10  There are lots of these game as I'm sure you know, but this one was one of the better ones out there, good job

Sound: 10/10  It had good music that really did "suck" you in and kept me entertained while I killed badies. Fantastic music.

Glitches: 6/10  I did encounter a few big glitches that were kind of important, most importanta I had been doing great when all of a sudden the game just ended. It said I had -23 lives 

Depth: 8/10  Considering the number of cats that could be placed and upgraded you get an 8/10, though you could have gotten higher if you focused more on the enemies

Difficulty: 7/10  I played on hard and it wasn't that hard, rather methodical after 20 waves, just add more difficult enemies

Addictiveness: 9/10  Very good, most could play this game for a long time without stopping

Overall: 8/10  Put all the things together and it's a great game and deserves a lot of credit 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rating - 81/100

Thanks for the fantastic review! Did you download it because there are less glitches when it is downloaded

Um since this isn't a game some of the categories don't really apply I guess? Ok so I haven't had ANY really good projects so far but probably my best so far are a coloring contest (art), an art dump which isn't really related to Scratch but just for the art and two animations. If you have any tips for what I could add to make better animations since I'm just starting out in the realm of not-sloppily-made-5-minute projects that would be awesome. Unfortunately I can't have voice acting yet because my voice is uh...babyish to say the least :C Hopefully I can use my art skills in later projects (and maybe collabs?) Thanks! Links below:

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/spongebob123/3052528
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/spongebob123/3052473
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/spongebob123/3028708
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/spongebob123/2389501

Can u revive my Axiom OS . It is in my signature.

I've had a review shop... I know how hard it is! Could you review this please?

Last edited by iaoumeur (2013-01-22 11:46:30)

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Zparx/2772741

You can click my thumbnail. A very simple and addicting scroller (: Please be sure to read the instructions! (in the notes!) I'm looking forward to your review!

bullelk12 wrote:

phew, lots of jobs  . I'll do my best to keep up.

Ok good luck    It's ok if mine is finished later, there's a lot of better projects submitted for reviewing here.

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/FiremariomkiZX/2894487

Why not? You can review an alternate version if you wish (Rock, Roll, Marisa)