Scratch

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-12 14:31:22

I'll review any of the below:

Criteria:
Game:
Graphics(How good the graphics are) /15
Enjoyability(If it's fun) /40
Music(if the music is good) /20
Bugs(if there are any bugs) /25

OS:
Graphics(How good the graphics are) /15
Workability(If it's fun) /40
Interface(if the interface is good) /20
Bugs(if there are any bugs) /25

Simulation:
Graphics(How good the graphics are) /15
Accuracy(If it's accuracy) /40
Music(if the music is good) /20
Bugs(if there are any bugs) /25

Leaderboard:

Games:
1.Spectrum 2 by Wes64 95/100
2. Dot by iaoumeur 90/100
3.Generation: 4001 Gold by Borrego6165 89/100
4.Snake v1.0 by coinman 88/100
5.Mario Platformer by Friddle16 87/100

OSes:
1.Windows Techno 1.5 by Artemibry 87/100
2.SSOS 2.2 by Tierage27 84/100
3.List OS by Firedrake969 83/100

Simulations:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Last edited by Programmer_112 (2013-02-20 18:57:42)

Borrego6165 · 2013-01-12 14:46:58

This could be a game or simulation

numberonegamers · 2013-01-12 14:47:22

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/numberonegamers/3010774

Have fun

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-12 14:58:08

Generation: 4001 Gold by Borrego6165
Graphics 14/15
Enjoyability 37/40
Music 17/20
Bugs 21/25
Total: 85/100
My opinion: I loved this game! No obvious problems

Last edited by Programmer_112 (2013-01-14 09:21:49)

Borrego6165 · 2013-01-12 15:06:52

Programmer_112 wrote:
Generation: 4001 Gold by Borrego6165
Graphics 14/15
Enjoyability 37/40
Music 15/20
Bugs 21/25
Total: 85/100
My opinion: I loved this game! No obvious problems

If there were no problems then the score is too low, or what you should do is tell me why I lost each point.

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-12 15:09:03

Scratch Defense 5 by numberonegames
Graphics 11/15
Enjoyability 32/40
Music 14/20
Bugs 16/25
Total: 73/100
My opinion: Pretty good! There were a few major bugs, like how I couldn't place cats about a quarter of the time, and the game seemed a bit too much like BTD to me, but if the bugs were fixed, it would be nearly perfect

numberonegamers · 2013-01-12 16:15:27

Programmer_112 wrote:
Scratch Defense 5 by numberonegames
Graphics 11/15
Enjoyability 32/40
Music 14/20
Bugs 16/25
Total: 73/100
My opinion: Pretty good! There were a few major bugs, like how I couldn't place cats about a quarter of the time, and the game seemed a bit too much like BTD to me, but if the bugs were fixed, it would be nearly perfect

What's wrong with music? The bug happens when you don't download it and you do sometimes have to double click towers into place.

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-12 16:55:36

I'm pretty picky about music. There's nothing wrong with it. The bug was'nt horrible. Sorry if my grading seemed harsh. You really did a good job. Just not perfect . . . quite.

Firedrake969 · 2013-01-12 17:01:11

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2881879 and
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2767728

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-12 17:32:59

Won't be able to review for at least 10 minutes, but I'll do it ASAP.

Tierage27 · 2013-01-12 21:16:15

I have one made with Lists called SSOS. It's an OS project that I've been working on for a few days.

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-13 17:20:36

List OS by Firedrake

Graphics 7/15
Workability 34/40
Interface 17/20
Bugs 25/25
Overall 83/100
My Opinion: The OS was useful, workabe, and fun. The graphics was just a big list, so, not a great score there. I would also want to see it with a way to go to a "bookmarked" application (maybe multiple, with hotkeys). This has infinite potential with Scratch 2.0!

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-13 17:29:03

Fallout by Firedrake 969:
Graphics 13/15
Enjoyability 33/40
Music 16/20
Bugs 24/25
Overall: 86/100
My opinion:
The game was awesome! The sprites for the main character and goal were both great. The game was fun. The sprite had a small area around him that he didn't occupy, but would still kill him, but it was tiny. The "glow" idea was innovative and unique, and provided a huge extra challenge as you thought you were home free and bumped into a wall, bounced, and hit radioactivity. I would really want to see levels or hazards that alter your jetpack powers to be higher or lower for the duration of the level.

Firedrake969 · 2013-01-13 17:33:00

Programmer_112 wrote:
List OS by Firedrake

Graphics 7/15
Workability 34/40
Interface 17/20
Bugs 25/25
Overall 83/100
My Opinion: The OS was useful, workabe, and fun. The graphics was just a big list, so, not a great score there. I would also want to see it with a way to go to a "bookmarked" application (maybe multiple, with hotkeys). This has infinite potential with Scratch 2.0!

Check out my collab. xD

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-13 17:35:49

Borrego6165 wrote:
Programmer_112 wrote:
Generation: 4001 Gold by Borrego6165
Graphics 14/15
Enjoyability 37/40
Music 15/20
Bugs 21/25
Total: 85/100
My opinion: I loved this game! No obvious problems
If there were no problems then the score is too low, or what you should do is tell me why I lost each point.

Sorry about that. The music was good, but the limited number of songs made it repetitive in a game that was obviously intended to take a little time. I know that music takes lots of space, but optimization might be able to fit it in. The bugs were mostly visual; after a while, the screen would spaz a bit. The game was very fun, just not perfect, therefore, 37. The graphics were almost perfect, but the advisor graphics annoyed me, and he was always there.

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-13 17:40:57

SSOS 1.8 by Tierage27

Graphics 8.5/15
Workability 32/40
Interface 18/20
Bugs 22/25
Overall 80.5/100
My Opinion: It was pretty good, better than List OS on graphics because the title screen was awesome. The OS didn't have many commands, though, and some commands did nothing. Like /ping. It just said PONG!!. I really liked the virus, though. XD. The only bug(or just missed chance in programming) was that if you typed /help 2, /help dissapeared, and people might forget the commands. Instead, I would have a separate list on the side showing all the commands.

Tierage27 · 2013-01-13 21:43:16

Programmer_112 wrote:
SSOS 1.8 by Tierage27

Graphics 8.5/15
Workability 32/40
Interface 18/20
Bugs 22/25
Overall 80.5/100
My Opinion: It was pretty good, better than List OS on graphics because the title screen was awesome. The OS didn't have many commands, though, and some commands did nothing. Like /ping. It just said PONG!!. I really liked the virus, though. XD. The only bug(or just missed chance in programming) was that if you typed /help 2, /help dissapeared, and people might forget the commands. Instead, I would have a separate list on the side showing all the commands.

What about SSOS 1.9?
I'm also working on SSOS 2 soon, which is going to be awesome.

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-13 22:12:57

I didn't see a v.1.9. Link?

Stealth2800 · 2013-01-14 01:33:19

Glasonic OS

Borrego6165 · 2013-01-14 07:13:42

Programmer_112 wrote:
Borrego6165 wrote:
Programmer_112 wrote:
Generation: 4001 Gold by Borrego6165
Graphics 14/15
Enjoyability 37/40
Music 15/20
Bugs 21/25
Total: 85/100
My opinion: I loved this game! No obvious problems
If there were no problems then the score is too low, or what you should do is tell me why I lost each point.
Sorry about that. The music was good, but the limited number of songs made it repetitive in a game that was obviously intended to take a little time. I know that music takes lots of space, but optimization might be able to fit it in. The bugs were mostly visual; after a while, the screen would spaz a bit. The game was very fun, just not perfect, therefore, 37. The graphics were almost perfect, but the advisor graphics annoyed me, and he was always there.

Well you didn't have to click on him for advice, and there is a music playlist to choose which songs skip and which play in-game. Also, you can easily have custom music included into the playlist by changing one number in the program code. About the screen, it updates more smoothly in G:4013 (out now) which also has the music playlist removed and far more music involved.

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-14 09:21:20

Borrego6165 wrote:
Programmer_112 wrote:
Borrego6165 wrote:

If there were no problems then the score is too low, or what you should do is tell me why I lost each point.
Sorry about that. The music was good, but the limited number of songs made it repetitive in a game that was obviously intended to take a little time. I know that music takes lots of space, but optimization might be able to fit it in. The bugs were mostly visual; after a while, the screen would spaz a bit. The game was very fun, just not perfect, therefore, 37. The graphics were almost perfect, but the advisor graphics annoyed me, and he was always there.
Well you didn't have to click on him for advice, and there is a music playlist to choose which songs skip and which play in-game. Also, you can easily have custom music included into the playlist by changing one number in the program code. About the screen, it updates more smoothly in G:4013 (out now) which also has the music playlist removed and far more music involved.

I didn't see the playlist before, but now I see where it is. I'll change your score. Thanks!

Tierage27 · 2013-01-15 23:15:30

Programmer_112 wrote:
I didn't see a v.1.9. Link?

I just made SSOS 2, which added a ton of new things.

Programmer_112 · 2013-01-15 23:21:13

Tierage27 wrote:
Programmer_112 wrote:
I didn't see a v.1.9. Link?
I just made SSOS 2, which added a ton of new things.

I'll re-review it when I can

fredmaster45 · 2013-01-16 10:12:10

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/fredmaster45/3031010
prepare to be scared

Tierage27 · 2013-01-16 20:01:22

fredmaster45 wrote:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/fredmaster45/3031010
prepare to be scared

It's not scary.
The sounds are loud, and the graphics are derpy for the thing that is like Slendermen.

Scratch

archived forums

#1 2013-01-12 14:31:22

Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#2 2013-01-12 14:46:58

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#3 2013-01-12 14:47:22

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#4 2013-01-12 14:58:08

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#5 2013-01-12 15:06:52

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Programmer_112 wrote:

#6 2013-01-12 15:09:03

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#7 2013-01-12 16:15:27

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Programmer_112 wrote:

#8 2013-01-12 16:55:36

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#9 2013-01-12 17:01:11

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#10 2013-01-12 17:32:59

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#11 2013-01-12 21:16:15

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#12 2013-01-13 17:20:36

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#13 2013-01-13 17:29:03

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#14 2013-01-13 17:33:00

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Programmer_112 wrote:

#15 2013-01-13 17:35:49

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Borrego6165 wrote:

Programmer_112 wrote:

#16 2013-01-13 17:40:57

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#17 2013-01-13 21:43:16

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Programmer_112 wrote:

#18 2013-01-13 22:12:57

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#19 2013-01-14 01:33:19

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#20 2013-01-14 07:13:42

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Programmer_112 wrote:

Borrego6165 wrote:

Programmer_112 wrote:

#21 2013-01-14 09:21:20

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Borrego6165 wrote:

Programmer_112 wrote:

Borrego6165 wrote:

#22 2013-01-15 23:15:30

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Programmer_112 wrote:

#23 2013-01-15 23:21:13

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

Tierage27 wrote:

Programmer_112 wrote:

#24 2013-01-16 10:12:10

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

#25 2013-01-16 20:01:22

Re: Game/Simulation/OS reviews

fredmaster45 wrote:

Board footer