Scratch
archived forums
#51 2013-01-10 10:59:05
Re: Game Reviews!
Game review: Mine fall
Art: 7/10
The art was nice, again I can see you drew it yourself. If you added a few more obstacles then it would have got a better score.
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 6/10
I like the way it goes straight into the game. Although it was fun to play I feel you could add a couple of different obstacles, like a broken mine cart track that you have to avoid or something like that.
Originality: 8/10
Pretty original. I know there are other projects where you have to avoid obstacles just like yours but I haven't seen a mine cart falling before so well done!
Addictive? 8/10
I wanted to keep playing to get a high score! However I think it is a bit hard to get a good score so I think it should be 1 point for every rock you avoid, then the red dots could be 5 points or something...
My personal opinion: 7/10
A nice game to play when you're bored only I think it's a bit simple. But I really do like the images that you drew!
Total: 36/50
Title: Got free time? Have a go at Mine Fall!
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#52 2013-01-10 11:12:24
Re: Game Reviews!
Game review: Rocket game v. 2.0
Art: 8/10
Nice! I like the level designs, the rocket looks cool. But I think the graphics could still be polished up a bit though...
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 9/10
I like projects that have a storyline and are also fun. I liked your story, the levels were also sometimes challenging which was great! There was a small lag at the beginning so that made me crash but I'll ignore that though...
Originality: 8/10
I've obviously seen others like this on scratch but because you drew everything yourself it got you a high score so well done!
Addictive? 6/10
There were probably a lot of levels (I kept crashing so I don't know). But it got a lower score because when you crashed you went back to the beginning which made it frustrating and you might give up. Don't take this too harshly because I still found it addictive and I'm sure many other people will!
My personal opinion: 8/10
The game runs really smooth, you drew all the cool graphics yourself. What else can I say? Awesome game!
Total: 39/50
Title: A really fun rocket game!
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#53 2013-01-10 11:44:51
Re: Game Reviews!
Thanks for the review! I think though that the downloaded images make it look better. Making missions is a good idea, i've thought about ai drivers to compete against, but it's not easy to programm
Scratch's most realistic F1 simulator
Offline
#55 2013-01-10 19:54:24
Re: Game Reviews!
Hey! First of all, thanks so much for reviewing so quickly! You're awesome.
Second of all, I just want to say that I pretty much got what I expected as far as the scores. I meant for it to be hard, and now I guess I must have made it pretty much impossible XD but thanks so much!!!!!!!!!
Offline
#56 2013-01-10 21:18:28
- numberonegamers
- Scratcher
- Registered: 2012-07-12
- Posts: 100+
Re: Game Reviews!
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/numberonegamers/3010774
An updated version of my old scratch defense
Offline
#57 2013-01-11 10:42:08
Re: Game Reviews!
Urania2 wrote:
Hey! First of all, thanks so much for reviewing so quickly! You're awesome.
Second of all, I just want to say that I pretty much got what I expected as far as the scores. I meant for it to be hard, and now I guess I must have made it pretty much impossible XD but thanks so much!!!!!!!!!
That's fine! I'm just doing my job, it was a really good game!
Last edited by iaoumeur (2013-01-11 10:43:53)
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#59 2013-01-11 11:30:55
Re: Game Reviews!
BugGame
BugCraft
Bugworks
Halloween Game
The first 3 are incomplete, and the final has a few bugs that I am yet to stamp out.
Offline
#60 2013-01-11 11:32:01
Re: Game Reviews!
Splodgey wrote:
BugGame
BugCraft
Bugworks
Halloween Game
The first 3 are incomplete, and the final has a few bugs that I am yet to stamp out.
Sorry, there is a maximum of two projects per day. Chose two and then you can put the other two some other day.
Last edited by iaoumeur (2013-01-11 15:09:33)
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#61 2013-01-11 11:35:02
- Firedrake969
- Scratcher
- Registered: 2011-11-24
- Posts: 1000+
Re: Game Reviews!
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2510629
First ever game that worked.
Click the sign.
Offline
#62 2013-01-11 12:17:06
Re: Game Reviews!
Firedrake969 wrote:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2510629
First ever game that worked.
Sorry Firedrake969 but you have already submitted the maximum of two projects. I would have loved to review it but rules are rules...
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#63 2013-01-11 13:04:54
- sonicfan12p
- Scratcher
- Registered: 2011-11-16
- Posts: 1000+
Re: Game Reviews!
Hello iaoumeur, I'm here to invite you to participate in the top ten projects of the week thread. All you have to do is tell me which two projects you reviewed this week scored highest on your rating system every Friday. Thanks if you can help!
Why are the secret organizations getting all the attention?
Offline
#64 2013-01-11 14:06:10
Re: Game Reviews!
sonicfan12p wrote:
Hello iaoumeur, I'm here to invite you to participate in the top ten projects of the week thread. All you have to do is tell me which two projects you reviewed this week scored highest on your rating system every Friday. Thanks if you can help!
Ok, Thanks! Great idea! I've put two projects on your forum thread.
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#65 2013-01-11 14:55:58
- Firedrake969
- Scratcher
- Registered: 2011-11-24
- Posts: 1000+
Re: Game Reviews!
iaoumeur wrote:
Firedrake969 wrote:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2510629
First ever game that worked.Sorry Firedrake969 but you have already submitted the maximum of two projects. I would have loved to review it but rules are rules...
I thought it was per day or something.
Click the sign.
Offline
#66 2013-01-11 15:06:01
Re: Game Reviews!
Firedrake969 wrote:
iaoumeur wrote:
Firedrake969 wrote:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Firedrake969/2510629
First ever game that worked.Sorry Firedrake969 but you have already submitted the maximum of two projects. I would have loved to review it but rules are rules...
I thought it was per day or something.
Ok I guess I could do that, it was just that you gave me too much the first time so the rules have now changed. YOU CAN SUBMIT A TOTAL OF TWO PROJECTS PER DAY. There, now your review will come shortly...
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#67 2013-01-11 15:17:46
Re: Game Reviews!
Game review: Air raid
Art: 4/10
Meh... Sorry Firedrake969 but really? I think you only drew the missile things and the spheres. I think you're other projects were a lot better...
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 5/10
It was fun alright but for someone like you I would have expected more complex ideas. I liked the fuel idea and that monster that came in but the game was very glitchy...
Originality: 5/10
So this is pretty original but you could have drew the other sprites rather than using the scratch one's. I know they are great to use but I prefer projects that are drawn by the user.
Addictive? 7/10
It was quite addictive. I liked the fuel tanks falling through the sky but you couldn't collect them. The monster idea was cool, I liked the constant missiles being fired but to be honest. I expected more.
My personal opinion: 5/10
I think I've expressed my point. I'm sorry Firedrake969 but I feel it was a bit simple and made quickly. However it was still really fun and addictive!
Total: 26/50
Title: Addictive air raid!
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#68 2013-01-11 15:23:41
- numberonegamers
- Scratcher
- Registered: 2012-07-12
- Posts: 100+
Re: Game Reviews!
iaoumeur wrote:
Game review (Updated review): Scratch Defense
Art: 8.5/10
The art work is still as cool as before if not better! I really like the heli-cat!
Storyline (If there is one, if not then how entertaining): 9.5/10
Still very entertaining, this improved by a bit because of you added an extra two stages which was cool and there is also a difficulty level which is awesome!
Originality: 10/10
(Same as last time) I have seen many defense games before but this is unique, using the scratch cat was a great idea!
Addictive? 9/10
Again it was really addictive, went up a mark because you added more stages so well done
My personal opinion: 8/10
I know this was better than the last one but that doesn't mean my opinion is better. I really like how you added more stages but I feel there were more glitches like the last one. Some of the cats were disappearing and when you bought a cat (or tower) there range stayed and you couldn't get rid of it so it was hard to see anything else. However it is still a great game and I still like the scratch cat idea!
Total: 45/50 (again, sorry...)
Title: Slightly improved awesome defense game!
Did you download it because it works way better when downloaded with no glitches
Offline
#69 2013-01-11 15:32:32
- Firedrake969
- Scratcher
- Registered: 2011-11-24
- Posts: 1000+
Re: Game Reviews!
iaoumeur wrote:
Game review: Air raid
Art: 4/10
Meh... Sorry Firedrake969 but really? I think you only drew the missile things and the spheres. I think you're other projects were a lot better...
Storyline(if there is one, if not then how enjoyable): 5/10
It was fun alright but for someone like you I would have expected more complex ideas. I liked the fuel idea and that monster that came in but the game was very glitchy...
Originality: 5/10
So this is pretty original but you could have drew the other sprites rather than using the scratch one's. I know they are great to use but I prefer projects that are drawn by the user.
Addictive? 7/10
It was quite addictive. I liked the fuel tanks falling through the sky but you couldn't collect them. The monster idea was cool, I liked the constant missiles being fired but to be honest. I expected more.
My personal opinion: 5/10
I think I've expressed my point. I'm sorry Firedrake969 but I feel it was a bit simple and made quickly. However it was still really fun and addictive!
Total: 26/50
Title: Addictive air raid!
That was my first game that actually worked. 
Surprised it even got 20! xD
Click the sign.
Offline
#70 2013-01-12 06:28:25
Re: Game Reviews!
numberonegamers wrote:
iaoumeur wrote:
Game review (Updated review): Scratch Defense
Art: 8.5/10
The art work is still as cool as before if not better! I really like the heli-cat!
Storyline (If there is one, if not then how entertaining): 9.5/10
Still very entertaining, this improved by a bit because of you added an extra two stages which was cool and there is also a difficulty level which is awesome!
Originality: 10/10
(Same as last time) I have seen many defense games before but this is unique, using the scratch cat was a great idea!
Addictive? 9/10
Again it was really addictive, went up a mark because you added more stages so well done
My personal opinion: 8/10
I know this was better than the last one but that doesn't mean my opinion is better. I really like how you added more stages but I feel there were more glitches like the last one. Some of the cats were disappearing and when you bought a cat (or tower) there range stayed and you couldn't get rid of it so it was hard to see anything else. However it is still a great game and I still like the scratch cat idea!
Total: 45/50 (again, sorry...)
Title: Slightly improved awesome defense game!Did you download it because it works way better when downloaded with no glitches
I did try to download it but it still had a few glitches so it balances out. But don't take this personally, it was a really good game!
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline
#74 2013-01-12 13:21:33
Re: Game Reviews!
danchy13 wrote:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/danchy13/3034072
Could You Rate My Most Recent Game Please!
Sorry, I only review games... This doesn't really count as a game... I checked it out though and it's really good! It reminds me of minecraft!
Last edited by iaoumeur (2013-01-12 13:21:55)
The Dot 3 is out!!! Play it here!
Offline