Scratch

The Current Criteria is: [6th December- (at least 2.0)]

The criteria is different per project:

Games :
Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) /10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?) /10
Sounds (Sound Effects, Music, Required?) /10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) /10
Entertaining (Fun, Addictive) /10
Plot (surprises? Changes?) /10
Gamer-Friendliness (Instructions, Hard, Easy) /10
Idea (Original, Remix?) /10
Re-Playability (Keep you playing) /10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) /10
Total /100

OS’s:
Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) /10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?, Run Well?) /10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) /10
Sound (Music, Required?) /10
Simplicity /10
Entertaining (Fun, Addictive) /10
User-Friendliness (complexity, can the user understand what they are doing?) /10
Apps (e.g. calculator, word processor) /10
Originality (Is it similar to other OS’s?) /10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) /10
Total /100

Animations and Videos:

Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) /10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?) /10
Music (Required?) /10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) /10
Idea (Original, Remix?) /10
Entertaining (Is it fun to watch?) /10
User-Friendliness (Is it easy to get? Instructions) /10
Plot (Story, Characters) /10
Effects (Sound, Animation) /10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) /10
Total /100

Beta's:

Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) /10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Run Well?) /10
Completeness (How far is it off being finished?) /10
Effort (How much effort is being put in to complete it?) /10
Entertaining (Fun, Addictive) /10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) /10
Sound (Music, Required?) /10
Idea (Original, Remix?) /10
User-Friendliness (complexity, can the user understand what they are doing?) /10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) /10
Total /100

Educational/ Informative:
Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) /10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?) /10
Music (Required?) /10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) /10
Idea (Original, Remix?) /10
User-Friendliness (Is it easy to get? Instructions) /10
Involvement (does it keep the player interested?)
Effectiveness (does it actually help the player?)
Detail (amount of info) /10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) /10
Total /100

Could you review OS Thunder? It is still in early stages, but I would like an honest review 

Thanks
-S

The link: OS Thunder

I tried to update my leaderboard project to celebrate the end of the old criteria and i had finished when i got hit by the disappearing text bug and i have lost everything. I may try again this weekend once i have calmed down- the most annoying thing is i saved it just before it happened several times but it still lost all the info.

Last edited by Willpower_Reviews (2012-12-07 11:55:24)

how about http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Wes64/2965449?

ill go with animation and videos.    thanks in advance!

Guess what's being released in a couple of days... my epic terrain generator! It's basically a BETA for the new Generation: Cities God Mode, so I'm releasing it separately so that I can get early feedback.

Hope you'll be still here to review it!

Last edited by Borrego6165 (2012-12-08 04:20:01)

Borrego6165 wrote:

Guess what's being released in a couple of days... my epic terrain generator! It's basically a BETA for the new Generation: Cities God Mode, so I'm releasing it separately so that I can get early feedback.

Hope you'll be still here to review it!

Of course i will be here- i have only just got new criteria so there is no point stopping and i don't want to anyway 

fillergames with Grumpy Cat The Game

Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) 8/10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?) 7/10
Sounds (Sound Effects, Music, Required?) 3/10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) 6/10
Entertaining (Fun, Addictive) 6/10
Plot (surprises? Changes?) 7/10
Gamer-Friendliness (Instructions, Hard, Easy) 7/10
Idea (Original, Remix?) 7/10
Re-Playability (Keep you playing) 5/10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) 6/10
A really funny video although the video does not seem to relate much to the game apart from the character. Prehaps some future enemies could be "ticklers" and they try and tickle Grumpy Cat. I completed it!
Total 62/100

Firedrake969 with Fight sim test

Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) 10/10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?) 8/10
Sounds (Sound Effects, Music, Required?) 3/10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) 9/10
Entertaining (Fun, Addictive) 7/10
Plot (surprises? Changes?) 4/10
Gamer-Friendliness (Instructions, Hard, Easy) 7/10
Idea (Original, Remix?) 8/10
Re-Playability (Keep you playing) 5/10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) 7/10
A really cool simulator. Prehaps you could turn it into a whole flight simulator with different controls and things like that. Scored low on plot and replayability because nothing else happens but that is too be expected
Total 68/100

Okay; I just added the new, review section in my Shop Directory and I'm about ready to put you in, but before I do, what would you like as your banner? And what do you want said below your shop's banner? And how about your sample review?

Hey, I'm very close to putting in the scripts which allow you to place the tiles onto the field, I just need your opinion on the interface. I know I didn't really bother with a loading screen or menu, but if you saw that Generation:Cities BETA Menu I released then you'll know how it will start anyway.

Don't fully review yet!

see yours!

Wes64 with Textboard

Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) 10/10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?) 9/10
Music (Required?) 8/10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) 10/10
Idea (Original, Remix?) 10/10
Entertaining (Is it fun to watch?) 8/10
User-Friendliness (Is it easy to get? Instructions) 10/10
Plot (Story, Characters) 8/10
Effects (Sound, Animation) 10/10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) 9/10
Setting the benchmark high! I can see that this is based off of that text scolling by app althoug i did not know it was called Polyboard. I do have an improvement idea and that is different colours of the message because it is only blue at the moment. Also aren't sound sliders supposed to be highest on the right   
Total 92/100

Edit- Wrong account 

Last edited by Willpower (2012-12-09 12:19:02)

Wes64 wrote:

Willpower wrote:

Wes64 with Textboard

Scripts (Programming, how smooth?) 10/10
Issues (Bugs & Glitches, Incomplete?) 9/10
Music (Required?) 8/10
Graphics (Sprite Design, Stage) 10/10
Idea (Original, Remix?) 10/10
Entertaining (Is it fun to watch?) 8/10
User-Friendliness (Is it easy to get? Instructions) 10/10
Plot (Story, Characters) 8/10
Effects (Sound, Animation) 10/10
Personal Opinion (What I really think! This is the space for comments) 9/10
Setting the benchmark high! I can see that this is based off of that text scolling by app althoug i did not know it was called Polyboard. I do have an improvement idea and that is different colours of the message because it is only blue at the moment. Also aren't sound sliders supposed to be highest on the right   
Total 92/100

Edit- Wrong account 

it is not based off any app... i saw a scrolling text thing in the hall at school and i decided to make it. and the sound is supposed to be that way, but it was hard to drag the slider all the way left so i made it easier    glad you liked it!

it is very similar to the app though so that is what gave me the idea!