Scratch

Why is Jeff so overrated? It's the worst pasta i've ever read, no offense 

I think Squidward's Suicide is my favorite 

And i made a friend who likes creepypasta.

nama wrote:

Animeboy975 wrote:

Why is Jeff so overrated? It's the worst pasta i've ever read, no offense 

I think Squidward's Suicide is my favorite 

And i made a friend who likes creepypasta.

I like both of those a lot. Why is jeff your least favorite though?

It was really boring IMO.

"What's wrong mommy? Aren't I beautiful?"
I love that quote though 

Animeboy975 wrote:

Why is Jeff so overrated? It's the worst pasta i've ever read, no offense 

I think Squidward's Suicide is my favorite 

And i made a friend who likes creepypasta.

You hate Jeff.

But you love Squidward's Suicide.

Okay, please excuse me while I go and call the nice men in the white coats.

Animeboy975 wrote:

Why is Squidward's Suicide so overrated? It's the worst pasta i've ever read, no offense 

I think Jeff is my favorite 

There we go! All fixed up! 

Last edited by banana500 (2012-09-20 17:36:53)

Animeboy975 wrote:

banana500 wrote:

Animeboy975 wrote:

Why is Jeff so overrated? It's the worst pasta i've ever read, no offense 

I think Squidward's Suicide is my favorite 

And i made a friend who likes creepypasta.

You hate Jeff.

But you love Squidward's Suicide.

Okay, please excuse me while I go and call the nice men in the white coats.

Problem?
Jeff, was just violent, boring, and predictable and lame. And such a bad pasta is EXTREMELY OVERRATED.

Squidward's Suicide was weird and twisted, but unpredictable, written well, and just good in general.

Okay, I guess I understand why you don't like Jeff, but what I have a problem with is that you actually LIKE Squidward's Suicide. Now THAT is just weird.

Well, just tell that to Sami, then, because believe me, she is going to MURDER you. 

Animeboy975 wrote:

banana500 wrote:

Animeboy975 wrote:

Why is Jeff so overrated? It's the worst pasta i've ever read, no offense 

I think Squidward's Suicide is my favorite 

And i made a friend who likes creepypasta.

You hate Jeff.

But you love Squidward's Suicide.

Okay, please excuse me while I go and call the nice men in the white coats.

Problem?
Jeff, was just violent, boring, and predictable and lame. And such a bad pasta is EXTREMELY OVERRATED.

Squidward's Suicide was weird and twisted, but unpredictable, written well, and just good in general.

Are you kidding?  One of the traits of Jeff the Killer that made it great was that you could understand Jeff.  He's an actual person (not as in walking around, as in not just a series of emotionless words).  Liu (the story, not just the character) adds a lot to his person, too.

Squidward's Suicide was unpredictable because you kept expecting something besides, as you put it "[mindlessly, pointlessly, and without adding anything-ly] violent, boring, and lame."  It was only unpredictable because at least I kept expecting something good (for entertainment's sake) to happen.  I suppose that a fanfict (or rather, not-a-fan-fict) might be vaguely good, maybe something about the insane creator and something about how he saw eyes watching him everywhere, and made several episodes like it to express his wish to commit suicide himself, but was unable to for some reason.  But yeah, nothing should be judged because of a fanfict that had nothing to do with the creator of the original; you don't see people insulting MLP on the grounds of Cupcakes.

Maybe do you just prefer to have your pastas, and no creepy?

banana500 wrote:

777w wrote:

banana500 wrote:

Okay, I guess I understand why you don't like Jeff, but what I have a problem with is that you actually LIKE Squidward's Suicide. Now THAT is just weird.

Well, just tell that to Sami, then, because believe me, she is going to MURDER you. 

i dont think sami should be one to judge the opinions of others, let alone anybody here at all

I know, I was just joking.    Everyone knows that Sami loves Jeff anyway, so yeah.

But I do agree with maxskywalker, however. Jeff wasn't boring or lame. It was incredibly intrigueing, well-written, and had what every good pasta needs: a great villain. Jeff was the story that really introduced me to creepypasta (well, that and Come Follow Me).

Also, I'm sure you guys know about MrCreepypasta, right? He's so great. Listening to him reading Jeff is just awesome.

+1

Also, I have a feeling you'd like "Play With Me".

I think we should have "Pasta of the year 2012". Like people vote on one of these and the winner is best pasta for 2012? We should do it like a presedential canidate, where the two winners get to be runners up and then everyone votes on their favorite.

The list-
Jeff the killer
Happy Appy
Squidward Suicide
Mr.Widemouth
Eyeless Jack
BEN

Anyone have any ideas for the official list that i'm forgetting?

Last edited by ZedProduction (2012-09-23 18:23:59)

ZedProduction wrote:

I think we should have "Pasta of the year 2012". Like people vote on one of these and the winner is best pasta for 2012? We should do it like a presedential canidate, where the two winners get to be runners up and then everyone votes on their favorite.

The list-
Jeff the killer
Happy Appy
Squidward Suicide
Mr.Widemouth
Eyeless Jack
BEN

Anyone have any ideas for the official list that i'm forgetting?

Best of these was Squidward's Suicide.

Mr. Widemouth was AWFUL. It was NOTHING i expected from a title like that.

BTW, I have a new story for you guys on the user-made scary story thread.

mythbusteranimator wrote:

Jeff Shall Win

No, jeff was horrible

But Herobrine was worse

mythbusteranimator wrote:

Animeboy975 wrote:

mythbusteranimator wrote:

Jeff Shall Win

No, jeff was horrible

But Herobrine was worse

true
BUT JEFF TO THE END

Only the sequels deserve hate. >

+1

samid11 wrote:

Jeff is back was innacurate.

Jeff vs Jane... Just shoot me.

Jeff and Jessie... I wanted to rip the authors head off.

+1

samid11 wrote:

mythbusteranimator wrote:

samid11 wrote:

Yeah.

Plus I can't stand another pasta where Jeff dies.

Especially after Jane the killer T_T

Jane the Killer? 

Yep. A dumb pasta where this annoying copy-cat named Jane hates Jeff for no good reason, does horrible things, and kills him.

She's basically a Mary-Sue. She's "special" because she doesn't kill babies (like that makes her any better), and she says "Don't go to sleep: You wont wake up".

and don't FLIPPING GET ME STARTED on her sister, Jessie the killer, who's a freakish stalker who loves Jeff and did UNSPEAKABLE things to him.

Both are just NSFW May-Sue copycats.

That isn't even a creepypasta, just a stupid fanfiction.