Scratch

jackajacka · 2012-08-23 13:00:06

Wes64 wrote:
DEAR POSTERS: I have not forgotten about you. I haven't been reviewing due to working intensively on a game (Spectrum 2).

I will review your games when it is complete. Very sorry for the delay.

It is fine! big_smile

Haiming · 2012-08-23 13:44:09

Can you review this? Avoid the Bombs 3 Thank you.

Haiming · 2012-08-23 13:54:09

Can you also review this? Street War The graphics are supposed to be retro style. Sorry, but you have to download. smile

Last edited by Haiming (2012-08-23 13:54:33)

UltraAdam · 2012-08-29 02:06:02

Can you Re-view This please?! big_smile

UltraAdam · 2012-08-30 02:25:38

UltraAdam wrote:
Can you Re-view This please?!

Billybob-Mario · 2012-08-31 21:47:05

Can you please review Ball Quest? Thank you.

Kenichi10B · 2012-09-01 04:41:57

Wes64 wrote:
Blob Tower Defense by Kenichi10B - 79/100

Scripting - 23/30
The game seems to work quite well! Im a bit worried about those 250 sprites and 1000 scripts though.

Graphics - 15/30
Here is the game's flaw: the graphics are not very detailed. The game's graphics are nice, although I wish the playing field was a bit more neutral-colored. Its bright and distracting. The menu graphics especially need a lot more detail.

Gameplay - 28/30
This... is really fun. I like the strategy! If I didnt have to review like 5 more games id play for another 30 minutes.

Concept 8/10

Sound - 3
I wish you used professional sound effects instead of the built-in ones, but I like the music.

Attitude - 2

Thanks for the review! I'm pretty bad with graphics, so that is kind of my downfall. I'm glad you reviewed though, because I've been wondering how to make it better (The graphics are definetly bad, though). Thanks! smile

Kenichi10 · 2012-09-01 20:17:45

Simple little game I made:

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/Kenichi10/2755620

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:10:15

BlockBusters Beta 0.1 by CoolScrawl - 63/100

Scripting - 22/30
Nice scripting! I like the water physics.

Graphics - 16/30
The graphics are not very appealinng or detailed, and the background doesn't even have clouds. The game could use more detail and some shading.

Gameplay - 15/30
There is no goal to the game. You just jump around and interact with the terrain. Its cool for a bit but then it gets boring.

Concept 5/10
Ive seen many minecraft-type games.

Sound - 2

Attitude - 3

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:15:57

Reptile 1s1s by jackajacka - 66/100

Scripting - 22/30
Nicely scripted, but it doesn't work online so ill have to take off points for that. (see gameplay for more)

Graphics - 16/30
The graphics are nice, but the gridded background is a bit hard on my eyes. I wish it was softer colored.

Gameplay - 18/30
The controls lack responding speed. Sometimes I predd the button and the snake turns right away, other times it seems to lag. This doesn't happen online so its most likely the render script lagging.

Concept 5/10
Ive seen many snake games before.

Sound - 2
I HATE skillrex's music. It sounds like a malfunctioning air conditioner. But I must remain unbisased.

Attitude - 3

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:18:44

Little Green Man-1s1s by AgentRoop - 87/100 (Review #2)

Scripting - 25/30

Graphics - 20/30

Gameplay - 26/30

Concept 7/10

Sound - 4
(+2)

Attitude - 5
(+2)

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:25:57

Pyramid Solitaire by benjamin2 - 90/100

Welcome to the hall of fame!

Scripting - 25/30
The game seems to work really well! I never won, but its really good.

Graphics - 20/30
The graphics could use some more detail, especially the background. The cards are creatively drawn but the scratch cat's head looks compressed and jagged. Also, id rather see stamped score displays rather than variable monitors.

Gameplay - 28/30
This is really fun and addicting! I played three times.

Concept 10/10
I dont think ive seen a solitaire game on Scratch before.

Sound - 4
Well done sound!

Attitude - 3

epninja · 2012-09-02 17:30:45

A review on EPNinjaObjective please. http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/epninja/2756104. Thanks if you do.

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:34:54

I'm So Proud of You by henley - 56/100

Scripting - 12/30
I fall through the ground a lot, and this is a big problem. Even though you can press 9 to get out, it still should be fixed. The platformer engine works well, but sometimes the top hit detection seems a bit off. You could have had 22 but I took off points for the glitches.

Graphics - 18/30
The graphics are ok, the gradients and solid colors seem a bit overused. The maps could use more detail.

Gameplay - 18/30
TThe game is kinda boring and not that challenging. It isn't even possible to lose! Talking to people is fun though.

Concept 4/10
Platformers aren't thet unique.

Sound - 0
Lacks sounds.

Attitude - 4

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:36:46

epninja wrote:
A review on EPNinjaObjective please. http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/epninja/2756104. Thanks if you do.

i know

i have to get through older reviews first

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:40:06

Shift by UltraAdam - 65/100

Scripting - 20/30
The scripting i Ok but there isn't enough friction. The player seems to float around, and when you win a level the velocity is not reset so you fly into obstacles.

Graphics - 18/30
The graphics are OK but some of the levels seem messily drawn.

Gameplay - 20/30
The game is fun, but some of the level design seems uninspired and generic. It could use more intricate levels.

Concept 3/10
Platformer.

Sound - 2

Attitude - 2

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:44:27

The Brick Destroyer II by ErnieParke - 82/100

Scripting - 23/30
The scripting is good! Some of the menus take too long to fade out though.

Graphics - 21/30
The graphics are nice, byt the "cracked" sprited for the orange blocks look hasty, and the stat display to the right is just black and white. I liked the scrolling stars though.

Gameplay - 23/30
The gameplay is fun, but I think it could be more exciting. It gets a bit monotonous just breaking blocks, and there isn't really any strategy involved.

Concept 6/10

Sound - 5

Attitude - 4

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 17:45:38

Reviews will trickle in whenever i've got time. Dont expect your reviews to get done for a while - ive got a massive backlog. So just be patient.

medog · 2012-09-02 19:02:05

Could you please review countrycreator?

Thanks!

ErnieParke · 2012-09-02 19:27:26

Leader Board:

Top 16 projects:

(1st) Ms. Pac-Man by ifugu - 100/100
(2nd) Generation- 4000 by Borrego6165 - 97/100
(3rd) Chomp by OverPowered - 91/100
(4th) Pyramid Solitaire by benjamin2 - 90/100
(5th) Dangerous Dungeons 0.3 by letmethink - 88/100
(6th) Little Green Man-1s1s by AgentRoop - 87/100 (Review #2)
(~7th) Project Armada FULL by radicalace - 86/100
(~7th) Castle Defense by Blitz_ - 86/100
(9th) Little Green Man-1s1s by AgentRoop - 83/100
(~10th) Cyber Defense by Zparx (Review #2) - 82/100
(~10th) The Brick Destroyer II by ErnieParke - 82/100
(12th) Pixel Run by thebriculator - 80/100
(13th) Avoid Gobo: an exercise in sleep-deprived game design by cpumaster930 - 80/100
(~14th) Geometry Field by TecklopAlternative - 79/100
(~14th) Blob Tower Defense by Kenichi10B - 79/100
(~14th) Dark and Light (1s1s) by AtomicBawm3 - 79/100

—•—•—•—•—•—

17th to 30th:

(~17th) The Arrow 1.2 by wolfdude999 - 76/100
(~17th) Vortex ! by Zparx - 76/100
(~17th) Stik by BirdByte - 76/100
(~20th) RAZOR by jackajacka - 75/100
(~20th) pixel 2 preview 3 by ftf841 - 75/100
(~20th) portal race (tributo a portal) by katzisc - 75/100
(~20th) Technocolor: Blue (1s1s) by berberberber - 75/100
(24th) Abstract by northmeister - 74/100
(25th) Revolution by jackajacka (Review #2) - 73/100
(26th) Rotator Alpha V 1.1 by zubblewu - 72/100
(~27th) Cyber Defense by Zparx - 70/100
(~27th) NHL 2K13 by VirtualCreations - 70/100
(~29th) BOX 1.0- Programming by ROSMan - 68/100
(~29th) MiniCraft by CheeseMunchy - 68/100

—•—•—•—•—•—

31st to 46th:

(~31st) Worm Bridges 2 by CoolScrawl - 67/100
(~31st) Escape The House by CheeseMunchy - 67/100
(~31st) Inversion:Platformer Game by beyblade4 - 67/100
(~34th) Darkness by overlordcujko - 66/100
(~34th) Revenge-WWIII Revenge of the Fallen( Full Game) by beyblade4 - 66/100
(~34th) Reptile 1s1s by jackajacka - 66/100
(~37th) Hopeless 1s1s by jackajacka - 65/100
(~37th) Estas muerto (10+) by katzisc - 65/100
(~37th) Revolution by jackajacka - 65/100
(~37th) Space Pirate V- Loot and Pillage by Happypieman - 65/100
(~37th) Shift by UltraAdam - 65/100
(42th) ~ C r y p t ~ ~Alpha~ by pipercubjl - 64/100
(~43st) FlashCraft beta 1.0 by Blitz_ - 63/100
(~43st) Worm Bridges 3 by CoolScrawl - 63/100
(~43st) Commando by BenF10 - 63/100
(~43st) BlockBusters Beta 0.1 by CoolScrawl - 63/100

—•—•—•—•—•—

47th and lower:

(47th) UNDERWATER ADVENTURES! by marcin388 - 62/100
(48th) Penguin attack! by zubblewu - 58/100
(~49th) AROBALL 3 by UltraAdam (Review #2)- 56/100
(~49th) I'm So Proud of You by henley - 56/100
(~51st) Pest by ROSMan - 55/100
(~51st) The Level Game! (100 levels!) by benjamin2 - 55/100
(~53rd) 30 Floors Beta by Nomolos - 54/100
(~53rd) AROBALL 3 by UltraAdam - 54/100
(55th) Zombie Apocalypse: Dead End (v1.0.1) by nano852 - 53/100
(56th) Mine Fall by calebxy - 52/100
(~57th) Doctor Who - Day of the Moon - boss battle by calebxy - 50/100
(~57th) Battle Of The Smilies by CyanCyndaquil - 50/100
(59th) Space Adventures by marcin388 - 45/100
(60th) Bit OS 1.0 by ftf841 - 44/100
(61st) Aroball 4 by UltraAdam - 42/100
(62nd) Two Player Pong! by maxdoss - 41/100
(63rd) Ma B'day + balloon bash minigame by dudey100 - 38/100
(64th) SpacePanicv0.4 by erl16 - 37/100
(65th) Trivia Quiz by sonicgames20 - 20/100

Last edited by ErnieParke (2012-09-02 22:18:37)

AgentRoop · 2012-09-02 21:36:53

ernieparke, cool leaderboard!

ErnieParke · 2012-09-02 22:03:55

AgentRoop wrote:
ernieparke, cool leaderboard!

Thanks! It took me around an hour to make.

gamer2012 · 2012-09-02 22:06:36

ErnieParke wrote:
Leader Board:

Top 16 projects:

(1st) Ms. Pac-Man by ifugu - 100/100
(2nd) Generation- 4000 by Borrego6165 - 97/100
(3rd) Chomp by OverPowered - 91/100
(4th) Pyramid Solitaire by benjamin2 - 90/100
(5th) Dangerous Dungeons 0.3 by letmethink - 88/100
(6th) Little Green Man-1s1s by AgentRoop - 87/100 (Review #2)
(~7th) Project Armada FULL by radicalace - 86/100
(~7th) Castle Defense by Blitz_ - 86/100
(9th) Little Green Man-1s1s by AgentRoop - 83/100
(~10th) Cyber Defense by Zparx (Review #2) - 82/100
(~10th) The Brick Destroyer II by ErnieParke - 82/100
(12th) Pixel Run by thebriculator - 80/100
(13th) Avoid Gobo: an exercise in sleep-deprived game design by cpumaster930 - 80/100
(~14th) Geometry Field by TecklopAlternative - 79/100
(~14th) Blob Tower Defense by Kenichi10B - 79/100
(~14th) Dark and Light (1s1s) by AtomicBawm3 - 79/100

—•—•—•—•—•—

17th to 30th:

(~17th) The Arrow 1.2 by wolfdude999 - 76/100
(~17th) Vortex ! by Zparx - 76/100
(~17th) Stik by BirdByte - 76/100
(~20th) RAZOR by jackajacka - 75/100
(~20th) pixel 2 preview 3 by ftf841 - 75/100
(~20th) portal race (tributo a portal) by katzisc - 75/100
(~20th) Technocolor: Blue (1s1s) by berberberber - 75/100
(24th) Abstract by northmeister - 74/100
(25th) Revolution by jackajacka (Review #2) - 73/100
(26th) Rotator Alpha V 1.1 by zubblewu - 72/100
(~27th) Cyber Defense by Zparx - 70/100
(~27th) NHL 2K13 by VirtualCreations - 70/100
(~29th) BOX 1.0- Programming by ROSMan - 68/100
(~29th) MiniCraft by CheeseMunchy - 68/100

—•—•—•—•—•—

31st to 46th:

(~31st) Worm Bridges 2 by CoolScrawl - 67/100
(~31st) Escape The House by CheeseMunchy - 67/100
(~31st) Inversion:Platformer Game by beyblade4 - 67/100
(~34th) Darkness by overlordcujko - 66/100
(~34th) Revenge-WWIII Revenge of the Fallen( Full Game) by beyblade4 - 66/100
(~34th) Reptile 1s1s by jackajacka - 66/100
(~37th) Hopeless 1s1s by jackajacka - 65/100
(~37th) Estas muerto (10+) by katzisc - 65/100
(~37th) Revolution by jackajacka - 65/100
(~37th) Space Pirate V- Loot and Pillage by Happypieman - 65/100
(~37th) Shift by UltraAdam - 65/100
(42th) ~ C r y p t ~ ~Alpha~ by pipercubjl - 64/100
(~43st) FlashCraft beta 1.0 by Blitz_ - 63/100
(~43st) Worm Bridges 3 by CoolScrawl - 63/100
(~43st) Commando by BenF10 - 63/100
(~43st) BlockBusters Beta 0.1 by CoolScrawl - 63/100

—•—•—•—•—•—

47th and lower:

(47th) UNDERWATER ADVENTURES! by marcin388 - 62/100
(48th) Penguin attack! by zubblewu - 58/100
(~49th) AROBALL 3 by UltraAdam (Review #2)- 56/100
(~49th) I'm So Proud of You by henley - 56/100
(~51st) Pest by ROSMan - 55/100
(~51st) The Level Game! (100 levels!) by benjamin2 - 55/100
(~53rd) 30 Floors Beta by Nomolos - 54/100
(~53rd) AROBALL 3 by UltraAdam - 54/100
(55th) Zombie Apocalypse: Dead End (v1.0.1) by nano852 - 53/100
(56th) Mine Fall by calebxy - 52/100
(~57th) Doctor Who - Day of the Moon - boss battle by calebxy - 50/100
(~57th) Battle Of The Smilies by CyanCyndaquil - 50/100
(59th) Space Adventures by marcin388 - 45/100
(60th) Bit OS 1.0 by ftf841 - 44/100
(61st) Aroball 4 by UltraAdam - 42/100
(66nd) Two Player Pong! by maxdoss - 41/100
(63rd) Ma B'day + balloon bash minigame by dudey100 - 38/100
(64th) SpacePanicv0.4 by erl16 - 37/100
(65th) Trivia Quiz by sonicgames20 - 20/100

Wow, that's a LOT of reviews, especially since all of them were reviewed within like 1-2 months.

Last edited by gamer2012 (2012-09-02 22:07:05)

thebriculator · 2012-09-02 22:46:50

no need to quote it all, gamer2012

Thanks for doing this, ErnieParke!
wow, I'm still 12th

Wes64 · 2012-09-02 23:01:10

OMG ERNIE THANKS SO MUCH! That's awesome! Ill have to remember to keep updating it myself.

Scratch

archived forums

#226 2012-08-23 13:00:06

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

Wes64 wrote:

#227 2012-08-23 13:44:09

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#228 2012-08-23 13:54:09

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#229 2012-08-29 02:06:02

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#230 2012-08-30 02:25:38

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

UltraAdam wrote:

#231 2012-08-31 21:47:05

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#232 2012-09-01 04:41:57

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

Wes64 wrote:

#233 2012-09-01 20:17:45

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#234 2012-09-02 17:10:15

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#235 2012-09-02 17:15:57

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#236 2012-09-02 17:18:44

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#237 2012-09-02 17:25:57

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#238 2012-09-02 17:30:45

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#239 2012-09-02 17:34:54

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#240 2012-09-02 17:36:46

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

epninja wrote:

#241 2012-09-02 17:40:06

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#242 2012-09-02 17:44:27

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#243 2012-09-02 17:45:38

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#244 2012-09-02 19:02:05

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#245 2012-09-02 19:27:26

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#246 2012-09-02 21:36:53

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#247 2012-09-02 22:03:55

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

AgentRoop wrote:

#248 2012-09-02 22:06:36

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

ErnieParke wrote:

#249 2012-09-02 22:46:50

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

#250 2012-09-02 23:01:10

Re: Wes64's Game Reviews

Board footer