Scratch

sonicfan12p wrote:

maxskywalker wrote:

sonicfan12p wrote:

I'm dissapointed with you guys, trying to disprove the credibility of several of my good friends, who don't pull pranks like this. Some of them are terrible liars, I can tell on there face if there lying. I didn't believe them at first, but I could tell they weren't lying. You guys keep coming up with logic for the burnings, but not the explosions. Or the weird structures, made out of seemingly random material. I want to know what happened, but what I'm stuck with is the hypothesis that herobrine was in there. I don't want to believe it, but you guys aren't helping disprove it. At all. I'm not convinced it was herobrine, I'm not trying to say it was. I'm saying that it is unexplained. Please do better with ideas  this time around, maybe we can figure this out.

*sigh* No one is trying to disprove your friend's credibility.  But Herobrine doesn't exist, and Endermen, Creepers, and lightning can all explain what you saw.

No, they can't. I already told you, creepers aren't powerful enough to do the damage that five of my friends saw, when separately asked, said close enough to thhe same thing, if they would have said the exact same thing I would have been suspicious, they looked dead serious when saying it, and three of them are incapable of looking dead serious if they aren't serious. I went and saw it myself, the damage is too great to have been a single creeper, as I said earlier, a closer estimate is 50 creepers all at once. Lightning, doesn't explode, so that's out of the question, endermen, pick up one block at a time, and I've never seen them pick up anything but grass, dirt, and tnt, and there was no tnt in, around, or near the house, nor was it even on the map. And I already said, I doubt it was herobrine, I don't really think it was, but the most logical answer I've received from you guys is a glitch, which still isn't logical because a glitch wouldn't look like aa comet crashed into your house. And what about the weird buildings, you still haven't tried to explain that. Now I expect you to stop trying to disprove herobrine by passing on things said from people you don't know, and start disproving him by proving something else did this. Good grief, use logic. Saying a creeper did it while you were thousands of blocks away is NOT logical people.

Maybe somebody else did it. Somebody real.

No
It was pseudo-Herobrine pasta

my contribution to the minecraft arts

Sonicfan, I've been reading your past posts and all I'm seeing is "HEY GUYS, HEROBRINE EXISTS! THIS IS EVIDENCE!" Given your posts, nothing you are saying is anywhere near proof. You got no pictures, no logical explanation for there not being coding. I think you are either lying to yourself about your friends, you are lying to us about it happening, or you have incoherent thoughts coherently constructed. Just give up, this has gone on for more than 4 pages... Geez.

RERAIL TIME!

I saw The Wither wiki page and I must say, he does look creepy. One thing - where would he spawn?

majormax wrote:

NeilWest wrote:

RERAIL TIME!

I saw The Wither wiki page and I must say, he does look creepy. One thing - where would he spawn?

The nether, perhaps in fortresses.

I hope he drops something good.

sonicfan12p wrote:

That's interesting cozyhut!    Now we know for sure what it is! I think...

Do you mean you think you think you know what kind of creature it is? 

okay so i just read all of page 345
like
what even guys

GameGuy64 wrote:

777w wrote:

okay so i just read all of page 345
like
what even guys

XD It was Herobrine

yeah i know
but like nobody was really offering anything logical and sonicfan12p was saying that everybody was against him and arguing with him which wasnt true

sonicfan12p wrote:

Checked the page, and a charged creeper is only twice as potent as a creeper, still not enough. Also, the only thing able to make a creeper explode is being near it, nothing else.

Here's another wiki page you should look at.

Notch wrote:

Getting loads of tweets and emails about Herobrine again. I don't have a dead brother, and he never was in the game. Not real. Never was.

sonicfan12p wrote:

I looked, and as I suspected, they had actual proof. Unlike you guys. Which I never tohught it was him, but that leaves us at square one. Noone has given any better ideas, as I specifically asked for.

how could anybody have given proof if you didnt supply any screenshots to show what the damage actually looked like

You only told me he never existed, without offering proof. random quotes and such is not proof, a professionally done wiki is. I'm losing hope with you, you're obviously not qualified to solve such a problem. Very well, I will look elsewhere. Anyway, to get back on topic, how about the wither?

I think we've all heard enough about whether Herobrine exists or not.  The conversation has moved from a productive search for the truth to a bunch of angry finger-pointing and name calling. 

Please remember in future conversations to treat each other more respectfully.

Last edited by Paddle2See (2012-08-28 05:44:54)