Scratch

Well, I will enter:
ScratchText
None yet
None yet

We need the judges scores. Anybody?

so should we be judging now?

Um... What?

Technoman
1 9
2 8.5
Average: 8 3/4
comments I would have given escape the classroom a 10 if longer.
Christian rock hard core is really hard! I only lasted a couple seconds. I suggest you have it start easier then get harder so the player can play some of the game without being eradicated, however it is a ton better than the average guitar hero spin off. 

Fireball123
1 10
2 9.5
3 9.5
Average 9 2/3
Mario Kart is awesome and you expanded on it by making four levels
The Stick was cool, however there should be more enemies, but the graphics were truly awesome and you have sound.
Fighter Ace got hard after the kamikazes, but that is late in the game so you can not lose all your lives in the beginning. I would have given you a 9 but the graphics were pretty good.

Dibbo22
1 9.5
2 9
3 10
Average 9 1/2
Bubble trouble was too long, by level 10 I was hoping it would end. except for that truly awesome. design your own scroller was good and original, but but it was laggy and your rounding was off. Also there was some blocks that had moved a little so the red stuff was higher then it should have been and I died.
Pika adventure was awesome

Flio5
1 8.5
2 9
3 8
Average 8 1/2
comments: Trapped was unfinished and rather unexciting. I didn't even know what the goal of the game was. Sentience syntiser or however you spelled it was pretty cool and original, however there was some important words you left out. abstractive renderer is but doesn't really do anything except draw a design.

Dav09
1: 6
2: 8
3: 8
Average: 7 1/3
The adventures of was your average scroller, and A LOT of the programming was clearly from Chop Shop. So I deducted 2 points because at least half of the programming was not your own. graphics were also lacking so I deducted some points. paint is your average paint program not to much special features. Scratch magazine was pretty short, some ads stuff like that so I gave it an average score.

Last edited by ellielli (2009-06-17 10:24:15)

ellielli wrote:

Technoman
1 9
2 8.5
Average: 8 3/4
comments I would have given escape the classroom a 10 if longer.
Christian rock hard core is really hard! I only lasted a couple seconds. I suggest you have it start easier then get harder so the player can play some of the game without being eradicated, however it is a ton better than the average guitar hero spin off. 

Fireball123
1 10
2 9.5
3 9.5
Average 9 2/3
Mario Kart is awesome and you expanded on it by making four levels
The Stick was cool, however there should be more enemies, but the graphics were truly awesome and you have sound.
Fighter Ace got hard after the kamikazes, but that is late in the game so you can not lose all your lives in the beginning. I would have given you a 9 but the graphics were pretty good.

Dibbo22
1 9.5
2 9
3 10
Average 9 1/2
Bubble trouble was too long, by level 10 I was hoping it would end. except for that truly awesome. design your own scroller was good and original, but but it was laggy and your rounding was off. Also there was some blocks that had moved a little so the red stuff was higher then it should have been and I died.
Pika adventure was awesome

Flio5
1 8.5
2 9
3 8
Average 8 1/2
comments: Trapped was unfinished and unexciting. sentience syntiser or however you spelled it was pretty cool and original, however there was some important words you left out. abstractive renderer is but doesn't really do anything except draw a design

I think you have to judge Dav09 too. 

greenflash wrote:

ellielli wrote:

Technoman
1 9
2 8.5
Average: 8 3/4
comments I would have given escape the classroom a 10 if longer.
Christian rock hard core is really hard! I only lasted a couple seconds. I suggest you have it start easier then get harder so the player can play some of the game without being eradicated, however it is a ton better than the average guitar hero spin off. 

Fireball123
1 10
2 9.5
3 9.5
Average 9 2/3
Mario Kart is awesome and you expanded on it by making four levels
The Stick was cool, however there should be more enemies, but the graphics were truly awesome and you have sound.
Fighter Ace got hard after the kamikazes, but that is late in the game so you can not lose all your lives in the beginning. I would have given you a 9 but the graphics were pretty good.

Dibbo22
1 9.5
2 9
3 10
Average 9 1/2
Bubble trouble was too long, by level 10 I was hoping it would end. except for that truly awesome. design your own scroller was good and original, but but it was laggy and your rounding was off. Also there was some blocks that had moved a little so the red stuff was higher then it should have been and I died.
Pika adventure was awesome

Flio5
1 8.5
2 9
3 8
Average 8 1/2
comments: Trapped was unfinished and unexciting. sentience syntiser or however you spelled it was pretty cool and original, however there was some important words you left out. abstractive renderer is but doesn't really do anything except draw a design

I think you have to judge Dav09 too. 

ya I know, I'm going to finish tomorrow. It took a little longer to judge because I included comments

greenflash wrote:

DavidTy wrote:

Juststickman:
1. 8
2. 6
3. 7
Average:  7

Magnie; 
1. 8
2. 6.8
3. 7
Average:  7.4

Kgordon :
1. 9
2. 8.7
3. 9.7
Average:  8.85

Is that for challenge two? because there are going to be two more participants

Oh sorry!

YES, I am winning contest number#2, FantasyTales might be trouble though.

EDIT: Yay, 100th post.

Last edited by kgordon (2009-06-17 12:41:08)

fireball123 wrote:

kgordon wrote:

YES, I am winning contest number#2, FantasyTales might be trouble though.

EDIT: Yay, 100th post.

Your average is 8.85 fantasytales can probably beat that (depends what projects he enters)

Still though, it could go up with my other judgings.

we need one more judge i think

boogawk wrote:

Can I judge?

Yes, contest 2