Scratch

MineCraft.

nyansonic wrote:

-5 Just Dance 3
+5 Minecraft
+4 mega man X
+4 mega man 2
+3  Portal 2
+2 conker's bad Fur day
+1 Sonic 3 & Knuckles

I dont think you can do that...

Bump

+4 Minecraft
+4 Portal 2

In my opinion

1st: fallout 2
2nd: fallout 1
3rd: DMC 3
4th: Heroes of might and magic 3
5th: civ 4
6th: super mario bross 3
7th: super mario bross 1
8th: fallout 3
9th: mafia 2
10th: Heavy rain
11th: Penumbra series
12th: Gothic 2
13th: Gothic 1
14th: Max Payne
15th: Black and White 2
16th: Black and White 1
17th: Lionheart: Legacy of the Crusader
18th: Medal of Honor Allied Assault
19th: Diablo 2
20th: Duke Nukem Manhattan Project
21st: Duke Nukem Forever
22nd: Warhammer 40000: Dawn of War Soul storm
23rd: Warhammer 40000: Dawn of War
24th: Rayman 2
25th: Icewind Dale 2
26th: Icewind Dale 1
27th: NFS Underground 1
28th: GTA 4
29th: DMC 4
30th: Thief Deadly Shadows
31st: Fallout New Vegas
32nd: Morrowind
33rd: Company of Heroes 1
34th: Crysis
35th: Master Rallye
36th: Red Alert 2
37th: Sacred
38th: FNR 3
39th: Skyrim
40th: NFS Most Wanted
41st: TDU 2
42nd: Spore

Probably there are many other games I forgot about which I could include in this list, even in my top 10.
For example Abe Oddyssey which I would place at 8th place but I didn't think of it while making the list.

Blair Witch Project I would add to my top 10

Last edited by marcin388 (2012-08-03 22:55:14)

SSBB and Minecraft

Here goes...
THe Penumbra Series
Amnesia
Limbo
Skyrim
Half-Life series
Scribblenauts series
Slender
Angry Birds (I know its an app STILL COUNTS)
Minecraft
The Binding of Issac
Team Fortress 2
Pesadelo (Free but amazing)
MCPixel
Ico
OneLateNight
The Cave
Pyschonauts (Yes, bobafett01 it has a spot)
Halo 4
Portal series
Tomb Raider: Underworld (I guess)
Super Smash Bros Brawl.
Star Wars Battlefront II
AAMFP
IWBTG
Façade
1916
Doukutsu
Haunt
Toy Story 3
ALL THE LEGO GAMES
etc.

CheckItNow12 wrote:

werdna123 wrote:

soupoftomato wrote:

yeah minecraft should rule and is the best game ever and no others have influence or importance because so bore

I never said that. I just said Pac-Man and Pong are terrible.

@CheckItNow:

Ah, I rate them on enjoyment, not importance. Pong was successful, yes. It used to be one of the best games, yes. But not anymore, people have made much much more fun games.

I know, you might hae gotten confused, because that was meant for soup.

I know, you might hae gotten confused, (and I never check this thread), but what I said was meant to be sarcastic.

Do you really think I would go around talking like that? 
'
Anyway, you really do need to consider the enjoyment of a game in this list. Also, amount of constant enjoyment. Minecraft is really fun but many parts ARE very grindy and simply done so that you can enjoy another aspect. And while yes, Pong isn't the most fun game around, it LAUNCHED the industry as a succesful commercial concept AND is still pretty enjoyable as a trial of skill. Pac-Man is still very fun, but I would say that I may arguably replace that with Mrs. Pac-Man now due to the implementation of an intelligent A.I. in that one. Super Mario Bros. is still an AMAZINGLY fun game, it may not hold up graphically but the enjoyment you get from has not by any means diminished. Tetris is still an incredibly fun, and challenging game, too.

Also, I did feature a couple of newer games (MK7 and Donkey Kong Country Returns) but thinking about it, I would include those while adding important predecessors. Obviously, the first MarioKart to set the precedent for Mario Kart 7 (IMO, the best Mario Kart I have played) and Donkey Kong (to introduce the character) and Donkey Kong Country (to introduce Country Returns concept).

I might also put on there Minecraft now, honestly. It's one of the breakout hit indie games that really made living off your indie game viable and added some popularity to the indie scene.

Then, there's Roller Coaster Tycoon which really remains as one of the best managerial simulators ever made.

Also, Civilization for being an amazing strategy and conquest game.

I'm certain there's more but that's what I can think of right now.

Last edited by soupoftomato (2013-02-27 20:45:34)

Okay well lemme say for the record that Minecraft, although it is a good game, it does not exactly hold up as "greatest video game of all time". It's certainly a groundbreaking game but at times I feel that the game mechanics either become too simple or even too convoluted. I've actually completely lost track of what they're adding to the game, and my friend said "Dude there are fireworks in Minecraft" and I said "Wait what".

Anyways I very much agree with Soup right now, Civilization is truly one of the best in the strategy genre.

So let me run down each game that I find to be truly the greatest games:

Half-Life (I'm surprised that there's little mention of this)
Super Mario Bros. (the NES version)
Pong (I've actually made a Scratch version of this which I'm quite proud of, Al Alcorn has played it himself, but that's a long story)
Pac-Man
Civilization
SimCity (this game really is the best in the "simulation" genre, Roller Coaster Tycoon is also cool, but man, SimCity, can't wait for the new game to come out)

Last edited by banana500 (2013-02-27 21:32:25)

soupoftomato wrote:

banana500 wrote:

Okay well lemme say for the record that Minecraft, although it is a good game, it does not exactly hold up as "greatest video game of all time". It's certainly a groundbreaking game but at times I feel that the game mechanics either become too simple or even too convoluted. I've actually completely lost track of what they're adding to the game, and my friend said "Dude there are fireworks in Minecraft" and I said "Wait what".

Anyways I very much agree with Soup right now, Civilization is truly one of the best in the strategy genre.

So let me run down each game that I find to be truly the greatest games:

Half-Life (I'm surprised that there's little mention of this)
Super Mario Bros. (the NES version)
Pong (I've actually made a Scratch version of this which I'm quite proud of, Al Alcorn has played it himself, but that's a long story)
Pac-Man
Civilization
SimCity (this game really is the best in the "simulation" genre, Roller Coaster Tycoon is also cool, but man, SimCity, can't wait for the new game to come out)

Nah, I still gotta go with RCT. I mean, SimCity 3000 (the only one I played) is pretty amazing (though I haven't played it recently, lost my disc), but Rollercoaster Tycoon is a lot more fun to me.

Elaborate on getting the creator of Pong to play your version? (Hack the Future?)

Oh god how did you know.

Pokemon Soulsilver
SSBB
Starfox 64
Scribblenauts Unlimited
Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
Super Mario Galaxy 2

soupoftomato wrote:

How could I forget Fire Emblem: Path Of Radiance?
I'm still waiting for another entry with Ike as the main character.

Ike is pretty awesome.