Scratch

Wes64 wrote:

BOX 1.0- Programming by ROSMan - 68/100

Note that this was not really a "game" so the score is lower. If I was reviewing programming tools, this would get like 80/100.

Scripting - 25/30
Great scripting here! I can see a lot of work went into this. It works great! I have to take you down to 25 though, because you used the "ask[]" block - It felt a little clumsy putting "E" "I" and "R" to input text, I would have preferred a button interface.

Graphics - 20/30
Nice clear menu graphics, but there are no graphics besides those and the few sprites.

Gameplay - 15/30
Gee, I don't know what to put here. This really had no gameplay, so ill give a score that can't help or hurt you.

Concept 8/10
Awesome concept - but its been done before.

Sound - 0

Attitude - 0

thanks!

NHL 2K13
The latest in the NHL 2K Series, a fun, arcade, air hockey-like Ice Hockey game!

Do you think you might have a go at it? 

Last edited by VirtualCreations (2012-07-20 20:25:20)

Wes64 wrote:

Geometry Field by TecklopAlternative - 79/100

Scripting - 18/30
Decent scripting, see "Gameplay" section.

Graphics - 30/30
Amazing graphics. (This is the first 30/30 I have ever given!)

Gameplay - 15/30
The gameplay is confusing. The "ZXCVB Space" controls are incredibly awkward. The individual lasers and stuff should be on a scrolling menu where the space key activates it, not assigned their own key. For someone like me who can't even type without looking at the keyboard, it becomes impossible to use all the weapons effectively because I have to keep looking. The player seems to move and turn too fast, and the enemies also move and turn too fast. The second round is impossible for me to beat, I just get game-over right away because I don't know what to do, and I cant hit them because they go too fast.

Concept 8/10
original.

Sound - 4
Well used sound effects but lacks music.

Attitude - 4

Thanks alot!, I love your review, it's very entertaining and knowing that i'll be changing the controls. again, thanks!

NHL 2K13 by VirtualCreations - 70/100

Scripting - 14/30
Average scripting.

Graphics - 18/30
Graphics are decent but some of them look like they are from Google Images.

Gameplay - 21/30
The game seems to work nicely, but I didn't know how to start the game - I had to press "e" but it didn't say so anywhere! Its fun!

Concept 9/10
I havent seen a hockey game on Scratch like this before.

Sound - 4

Attitude - 4

jackajacka wrote:

Can you review this, http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/jackajacka/2690713 and this, http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/jackajacka/2622604 Thanks!!!!!!

when gf clicked
repeat until <(AWESOMENESS) > [*]>
  go to [jackajacka]
end
think [Achived Awesomeness] for (EVER)

Ok ill review them. Don't post blockspam on the forums though, there's a topic for it here.

Revolution by jackajacka - 65/100

Scripting - 25/30
The platforming works really well, and I like the menu.

Graphics - 20/30
Block colors arw a bit boring, and the player isn't very detailed.

Gameplay - 12/30
This is a good game, but I have to take off a LOT because the player looks just like the guy who follows him around.
I can't tell who is who!

Concept 3/10
Almost identical to DropBear 1.

Sound - 2

Attitude - 3

Castle Defense by Blitz_ - 86/100

You are now the highest rated game.

Scripting - 25/30
The game works nicely and I cannot see any gliotches!

Graphics - 27/30
Very nice graphics! They are a bit small, but nice detail.

Gameplay - 27/30
The game is VERY fun, but when I get the turret I can destroy all the enemies instantly, and it becomes no fun.

Concept 7/10
Very unique tower defense game!

Sound - 0

Attitude - 0

Wes64 wrote:

Revolution by jackajacka - 65/100

Scripting - 25/30
The platforming works really well, and I like the menu.

Graphics - 20/30
Block colors arw a bit boring, and the player isn't very detailed.

Gameplay - 12/30
This is a good game, but I have to take off a LOT because the player looks just like the guy who follows him around.
I can't tell who is who!

Concept 3/10
Almost identical to DropBear 1.

Sound - 2

Attitude - 3

Thanks for the review wes! I am going to take out the friend. and make it look better. I know it is exactly like drop bear, I gave him credit as well. Could you review it again after I make more levels and get rid of the friend?

Last edited by jackajacka (2012-07-23 19:17:55)

Sure, ill review them again if you ask me when you're ready.

Wes64 wrote:

Cyber Defense by Zparx (Review #2) - 82/100

Scripting - 23/30
(+10) Now that the game is working properly, its great!

Graphics - 18/30
Now all you need to do is make the game more prettyful 

Gameplay - 27/30
(+2) Now that I was able to get into it, this game is really awesome!

Concept 8/10

Sound - 2

Attitude - 4

I didn't think you were going to re-review it! Thank you so much! (:

http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/radicalace/2692898

The reason the background is bland is because when I put the text over it everything was too jumbled so in the end I left it plain black.

thebriculator wrote:

I rate Spectrum with a 109/100, only so Spectrum 2 can top it. 

Lol thanks 

AROBALL 3 by UltraAdam - 54/100

Scripting - 16/30
The game works, but the scripting is very basic. You could use velocity, and I don't see why each "aro" has its own sprite.

Graphics - 16/30
Some of the levels look a bit messily drawn. The game's graphics could use a bit more detail as well.

Gameplay - 20/30
The game works well, and the gameplay is OK, but there isn't anything that addicts me to it. There's no "oomph".

Concept 3/10
This game overall reminds me a LOT of Blob. Aro=Blob, the same character select screen, same graphics style.

Sound - 1

Attitude - -2
I dislike when people use "Love-its scales" and add new things to the game based on how much love-its you get. You should be grateful for any and all love-its you receive, and not ask for more. I have nothing against you as a person, but you probably shouldn't do that.