Scratch

Please review my game project - SpacePanic!
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/erl16/2512190
Thanks!

wolfdude999 wrote:

I can help with the reviews.

OK

Can you please review 2 games in my signature?

Space adventures one you have to download to play, you can also use flash player but it messes up sounds.

Thank you

Space Adventures by marcin388
programming/complexity 15/20

the programming and complexity was good overall but you used an un efficiant movment script.

graphics 17/20
the graphics were pretty good.

gameplay 16/20
it was pretty fun

sound 18/20
you could add some more soundeffects

overall:

66/100

Last edited by ftf841 (2012-07-16 12:56:21)

Underwater Adventures by marcin388

programming/complexity score 5/20
the programming was very simple and unorganized.  Also, using obscenities for broadcast names probably isn't a good idea.

graphics score 1/20
no original graphics

gameplay score 12/20
the ability to speed up and slow down is nice but it can get very difficult at times.

sound score 5/20
had sounds but like the graphics they aren't original

overall: 23/80

Last edited by wolfdude999 (2012-07-16 12:49:38)

ftf841 wrote:

marcin388 wrote:

ftf841 wrote:

Space Adventures by marcin388
programming/complexity 15/20
the programming and complexity was good overall but you used an un efficiant movment script.
graphics 17/20
the graphics were pretty good.

gameplay 16/20
it was pretty fun

sound 18/20
you could add some more soundeffects

overall:

66/100

isn't it 66/80? 

no

I think it is, otherwise the best you can get is 80

wolfdude999 wrote:

ftf841 wrote:

marcin388 wrote:

isn't it 66/80? 

no

I think it is, otherwise the best you can get is 80

oh it is sorry i will add another section to make it 100.

ftf841 wrote:

Wes64 wrote:

Could you please review Spectrum?

wolfdude999 can you reveiw it? my computer crashed  when i tried to play it.

Ahaha my bad.

ftf841 wrote:

wolfdude999 wrote:

ftf841 wrote:

no

I think it is, otherwise the best you can get is 80

oh it is sorry i will add another section to make it 100.

ok can you update my rating please since you added another section? 

spectrum by wes64

programming/complexity 20/20
score says it all

graphics 19/20
VERY good

gameplay 15/20
it was fun but it was alittle confusing where to go.

sound 1/20
lack of sounds

originality 7/20
too much like pokemon.

overall:

62/100

for spectrum 2 add a soundtrack some sound effects and make it a bit  diferent than pokemon because it was a great game but it had a lack of sounds and it's not very original.

Last edited by ftf841 (2012-07-16 18:35:23)

Wes64 wrote:

I think you penalised me too much for sounds tbh. I physically could not add sound due to the massive size.

also you added wrong, its 62.

oh

xD I know your not gonna accept me as a reviewer, but i want to try it out.
I already reviewed my own game.

PixelBlip! by Ludburghmdm

Programming/Complexity 7/20
It wasn't so hard. Even a newbie with enough knowledge can make it 

Graphics 2/20
It's only pixels with random colors, nothing more, nothing less.

Gameplay 2/20
You just shoot enemies out of nowhere, sometimes no enemies even appear!
It's not even fun.

Sound 4/20
Its just beeps, and the music is just the same 8bit music loop.

Originality 10/20
It IS original, but not so much, as some minigames usually have this.

Overall:

27/100 - Very Poor

^ Wow, My game sucks, and i'm not afraid to admit it.

I rate the overall score like this:
0-10   - Awfully, Horrifically, Bad
10-20  - Very Poor
20-30  - Below Average
30-40  - Okay / Average
40-50  - Good
50-60  - Very Good
60-70  - Excellent
70-80  - Cool!
80-90  - Awesome!
90-100 - Perfectly Epically Awesome!

Anyway, if i do get in,.....YAY!