Scratch

Could you rate Abstract please 

Last edited by northmeister (2012-07-15 14:56:30)

Wes64 wrote:

Abstract by northmeister - 74/100

Scripting - 23/30
Although it is bug-free, I dislike how the player and walls interact. It seems sticky.

Graphics - 15/30
The colors are vibrant. Unfortunately there isn't much detail (it uses block colors) and the Level display is too large and obscures a good portion of the map.

Gameplay - 20/30
The gameplay is fun but there isn't really anything that draws me in and addicts me. It is also very straightforward. Some power-ups would be nice. Also the one-hit deaths start to annoy.

Concept 9/10

Sound - 2
There is a pretty nice song in the background but no other sound effects exist.

Attitude - 5

I know, I found the wall detection hard as it's the maze sprite that moves, and not the player, and it would have to interact differently depending on how the player touches the wall.

I tried to make the graphics really simple, yet abstract-ish, some people like it more than others    Although, I agree I could have used colours other than the block colours.

Hmm... there are sound effects, when you go to the next level and when you touch the red acid, did it not work when you played it? 

Anyway, thanks for the review! 

Lol...I like how you can get over 100 and less than 0...I guess you have to be pretty spectacular or pretty horrible to get either of those though.

Space Adventures by marcin388 - 45/100

Scripting - 18/30
Although there were no major flaws, the scripts are messy beyond belief.

Graphics - 12/30
The graphics are only OK. There is no real detail and some are messily drawn or edited.

Gameplay - 7/30
There are far too many controls to remember. Upon starting the game I got game over after 1 second. Once I got used to it, the controls were still choppy and the gameplay was boring.

Concept 5/10
Not really special in any way.

Sound - 3
Lacks music.

Attitude - 0

Thank you very much here I leave my two jewels for the you review
Portal Race
Estas Muerto

AtomicBawm3 wrote:

Lol...I like how you can get over 100 and less than 0...I guess you have to be pretty spectacular or pretty horrible to get either of those though.

I hope never to give out a negative score. Got anything you want reviewed?

What's with all the negative attitudes?

portal race (tributo a portal) by katzisc - 75/100

Scripting - 24/30
It works pretty well! I didn't find any glitches.

Graphics - 20/30
The car and health graphics are nice. The portal, missile, and shooting sprites are not as detailed, and they look weird next to the very detailed things.

Gameplay - 16/30
The game is pretty fun, but its also confusing. With all the portals, missiles and cars and explosions, it gets very confusing and convoluted.

Concept 8/10
An interesting blend of Portal, shooting, and cars.

Sound - 4
Well done sound.

Attitude - 3

Estas muerto (10+) by katzisc - 65/100

Scripting - 22/30
No bugs but its also VERY simple.

Graphics - 18/30
The graphics are decent, but nothing outstanding.

Gameplay - 15/30
The gameplay works but again nothing outstanding. Its just kinda bland.

Concept 4/10
Ive played a lot of shooting games and this one isn't outstanding among them.

Sound - 3

Attitude - 3

pixel 2 preview 3 by ftf841 - 75/100

Scripting - 22/30
The game works pretty well. The physics, however, need work. The jumping feels unnatural and is not smooth.

Graphics - 23/30
The level graphics and title menu look great. But the cubes for the player and enemy are pretty basic, and the help screen is just black text on a blue background.

Gameplay - 22/30
Its pretty fun, the health meter is a good idea. However the jumping, while also a scripting problem, interferes with my enjoyment of the game.

Concept 5/10
Its a platformer, Ive played too many of these to count. If you want 10/10 for a platforming game, you REALLY have to blow me away.

Sound - 3
I like the background music A LOT. But it needs more sound effects.

Attitude - 0

Bit OS 1.0 by ftf841 - 44/100

Note that this is an OS, not a game. This rubric was for games and it doesn't exactly apply to your OS. The paint programs work well, but I don't consider them games, which is why you lost a lot of points.

Scripting - 18/30
This is pretty basic. The paint programs work well, but what takes you down is the Pong game. It is glitchy beyond belief, and easily fixed too. Im taking off a lot for that. Also the variables shown in the "options" menu don't change.

Graphics - 15/30
There really isn't much to grade you on here. The options on the menu are un-readable because you colored the text blue. All the game's data is displayed through variable windows, which are ugly.

Gameplay - 5/30
Since this is an OS, and you knowingly asked a GAME reviewer to review it, i'm not going to hold back. The only "game" aspect of this was the pong game, and it was awful. The paint programs work well, but those aren't games. Sorry.

Concept 5/10
It doesn't do anything special. Ive seen many, many OS games and this is not outstanding amongst them.

Sound - 1
There was only 2 sounds.

Attitude - 0

Yes, I can definitely do better  . This was totally developed in 2-4 hours though, so I did what I could
In that time. And I would have made more efficient scripting if I had time, but I didnt. The graphics were actually in most things a square in the editor (4 pixels) each. Just thought id put it out there to see what you thought.