I think I've started a review craze here: Wes64, CoolScrawl, UltraAdam, henley and Nomolos (just to name a few) have made reviewers now
I will rate OS's and simulations too, and I'll give feedback on the project and give suggestions to improve.
I won't focus as much on a scale of 1-10, but I will have a scale just to be able to compare the games I rate. There's no 1-10 for every aspect of the game, like sound, graphics, addictiveness etc, I'll just give a 1-10 on the whole game. I will review every game/OS/sim you tell me to, and I'll comment on the project my review and the rating. Then, I will put a link in this post with the rating and a summary of what I think of the project.
Please don't be offended if I give you a low score, and if you feel I've got something wrong, feel free to reply and I'll see what I can do. I'll always give you constructive critiscm, I will never just say, 'That game is so stupid, I give it 1/10.'
All projects that get a 6> rating will appear below. You can have as many projects as you like reviewed.
1. Spectrum by Wes64 Project Rating = 10
Wes64 made it, what else can I say.
= The Level Game! by Benjamin2 Project Rating = 10
Outstanding brain wracking game by benjamin2, very original, really well done to him.
3. Generation- 4000 by Borrego6165 Project Rating = 9
An epic city sim by Borrego6165. Almost faultless. Amazing graphics.
4. Cyber Defense by Zparx Project Rating = 8
An awesome tower defence game where you have to stop the viruses infecting your files!
= Ninja Platformer by KROOOE Project Rating = 8
An addicting minigame where you have to survive by jumping on platforms.
= ~ C r y p t ~ by pipercubjl Project Rating = 8
An atmospheric start to an awesome game set in a dark, spooky crypt.
= Worm Bridges 3 by CoolScrawl Project Rating = 8
An interesting game by CoolScrawl where you have to build a bridge to let your character complete the level.
= RUN by Chrisbrown Project Rating = 8
A simple, addicting minigame where you have to get the fastest 100m time by pressing just 2 different keys.
9. Maze Leveler 2 by Notaloser Project Rating = 7
First just looks like a simple maze game, but then different aspects of the project prove it to be very addicting and challenging.
= Shift by UltraAdam
A cool, challenging platformer by UltraAdam.
= Shift 3 by UltraAdam Project Rating = 7
A nice ending to Shift by UltraAdam.
= Ultra OS by UltraAdam Project Rating = 7
A good base of an OS by UltraAdam; everything works.
= Sonic R by Calebxy Project Rating = 7
An awesome 3D Sonic game by calebxy.
= SpacePanic by Erl16 Project Rating = 7
A very good retro game by erl16 based on the game Space Panic made in the 80's.
14. Windows 7 by Notaloser Project Rating = 6
A nice start to an OS by notaloser, lots of apps and I couldn't find any glitches.
= Space Adventures by Marcin388 Project Rating = 6
A very hard game where you have to shoot down various enemies. The project has awesome sound effects!
= NHL 2K13 by Virtual Ceations Project Rating = 6
A cool hockey game by VirtualCreations with some really nice graphics.
= Doctor Who - Day of the Moon - boss battle by Calebxy Project Rating = 6
A cool Doctor Who shooter where you have to kill three enemies before they kill you with their lightning powers.
Last edited by northmeister (2012-09-03 14:17:23)
Offline
chrisbown wrote:
That is a very good idea, at least you won't say a project is rated a 1.
Yep. Do you have any projects you want reviewing?
Offline
daniel_j wrote:
Are you allowed to suggest your own projects? xD
\/ \/
Yep, that's the whole point :3 In fact, people might not want their projects rated, so you're only allowed to suggest you're own projects.
Offline
OK this is my win7 simulation (OS)
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/notaloser/2636219
And this is a cool maze game called Maze Leveler...
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/notaloser/2673444
Thank you!
Offline
Offline
Can you review these two games please?
First one is my first project on scratch, but still pretty good.
Second one is my biggest project ever.
Underwater Adventures
Second one (Space Adventures) you have to download to play because it is so big that it lags here on the scratch website.
Space Adventures
Offline
I've reviewed all those projects and added the ones with a score of 6> to the leaderboard
Offline
Can you review Spectrum?
Also your lettering system is confusing, instead of weird triangles and dots could you just write the rating?
Offline
Wes64 wrote:
Can you review Spectrum?
Also your lettering system is confusing, instead of weird triangles and dots could you just write the rating?
Ah, okay, I've changed it.
I think I know what rating Spectrum will get...
Offline
also I have this other project I would like you check
Estas Muerto
Offline
I'm going on holiday until Saturday, won't be able to review games until then.
Offline
^^^
lol I was just about to bump this not 10 minutes ago, but then I figured you'd do it yourself. Whaddya know.
Offline
Hi northmeister, could you review my game NHL 2K13? Thank you!
Offline
Wes64 wrote:
^^^
lol I was just about to bump this not 10 minutes ago, but then I figured you'd do it yourself. Whaddya know.
Yeah, I just got back from holiday and I only got 1 review D: I've got another one to do now, and I hope I'll get a few more!
Offline