Scratch

jukyter wrote:

Can we just stop arguing!? ;_____;
It's like every post on this topic is part of an argument about Nicki Minaj. The topic title isn't 'Most Significant' which is objective, but 'Greatest' which is subjective. So, fun, choose what you want-everyone else what you want.

That's what I was saying, but SOME PEOPLE wouldn't listen. 

Bohemian Rhapsody.

Imagine?
That song makes me want to throw up. 

edit: before a big argument starts, It's not that I don't want peace. I'm not willing to give up my faith in order to have it.

Last edited by ROSMan (2012-06-24 09:39:33)

I'm going to report this thread.
Really, everyone should get to have their own opinion on this sort of thing.
It should've been known that this would've caused flamewars right from the beginning.

I think it'd be better if everybody posted songs they liked, then songs could be eliminated from that huge list. Finally people would vote on THOSE nominees.

That way, people won't be arguing because if a song gets eliminated, nobody'll have anything to argue about.

Forget all this "significant" nonsense. This is about what the Scratch community enjoys. If a member of the Scratch community likes Nicki Minaj, than so be it. This isn't some professional critic's list; this is a list by some average people, so of course it will have some songs that haven't really changed music. Good songs don't have to have impcat; they just have to be GOOD. This isn't a list of the most important songs of all-time. We don't know for sure if Nicki Minaj is going to change anything. I doubt it, but that's really not important. We'd have to exclude all songs from the past few years if that happened (which would be plain biased).

sanddude wrote:

Good songs don't have to have impcat;

I disagree; all good songs need impcat.

funelephant wrote:

jukyter wrote:

Can we just stop arguing!? ;_____;
It's like every post on this topic is part of an argument about Nicki Minaj. The topic title isn't 'Most Significant' which is objective, but 'Greatest' which is subjective. So, fun, choose what you want-everyone else what you want.

That's what I was saying, but SOME PEOPLE wouldn't listen. 

I'm sorry to say this, but in part you're the problem. You're part of the 'SOME PEOPLE' as you put it.
I'm sorry. ;______;
The Scratch community shouldn't be arguing, especially on a topic as trivial as this. It basically amounts to this:

User1: *unpopular opinion*
User2: I disagree!
User3 I disagree as well and here are the reasons why your opinion is a failure!
User1: HOW DARE YOU!

And so on.

jukyter wrote:

funelephant wrote:

jukyter wrote:

Can we just stop arguing!? ;_____;
It's like every post on this topic is part of an argument about Nicki Minaj. The topic title isn't 'Most Significant' which is objective, but 'Greatest' which is subjective. So, fun, choose what you want-everyone else what you want.

That's what I was saying, but SOME PEOPLE wouldn't listen. 

I'm sorry to say this, but in part you're the problem. You're part of the 'SOME PEOPLE' as you put it.
I'm sorry. ;______;
The Scratch community shouldn't be arguing, especially on a topic as trivial as this. It basically amounts to this:

User1: *unpopular opinion*
User2: I disagree!
User3 I disagree as well and here are the reasons why your opinion is a failure!
User1: HOW DARE YOU!

And so on.

I was User 1 though.

funelephant wrote:

jukyter wrote:

funelephant wrote:

That's what I was saying, but SOME PEOPLE wouldn't listen. 

I'm sorry to say this, but in part you're the problem. You're part of the 'SOME PEOPLE' as you put it.
I'm sorry. ;______;
The Scratch community shouldn't be arguing, especially on a topic as trivial as this. It basically amounts to this:

User1: *unpopular opinion*
User2: I disagree!
User3 I disagree as well and here are the reasons why your opinion is a failure!
User1: HOW DARE YOU!

And so on.

I was User 1 though.

...um so?

sanddude wrote:

Forget all this "significant" nonsense. This is about what the Scratch community enjoys. If a member of the Scratch community likes Nicki Minaj, than so be it. This isn't some professional critic's list; this is a list by some average people, so of course it will have some songs that haven't really changed music. Good songs don't have to have impcat; they just have to be GOOD. This isn't a list of the most important songs of all-time. We don't know for sure if Nicki Minaj is going to change anything. I doubt it, but that's really not important. We'd have to exclude all songs from the past few years if that happened (which would be plain biased).

Well there's the source of the problem. When I see "greatest" I think the most influencial and significant. If this is a community vote it should be most "popular" songs of all time.

Thread of the Year 2012

jukyter wrote:

funelephant wrote:

jukyter wrote:

...um so?

Not user 3 

Yeah, you come state an unpopular opinion. Someone else says 'I don't agree.' Someone else blows it up a notch and you, instead of ignoring it take it up to 11.
I'm basically saying everyone's in the wrong here (except possibly User2).

There's nothing wrong with stating an opinion and defending yourself.

All4one wrote:

wiimaster wrote:

I wish I could choose more than ten...
I suppose its too late to rethink my ten, so here are some ideas for other people (VOTE FOR THEM):
Space Oddity // David Bowie
Ziggy Stardust // David Bowie
Your Song // Elton John
Crocodile Rock // Elton John
We are the Champions // Queen
Let it Be // The Beatles
Help // The Beatles
Sgt. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band // The Beatles
Back and Black // AC/DC
Livin On a Prayer // Bon Jovi
Don't Stop Believin // Journey
Thriller // Michael Jackson
The Final Countdown // Europe
Enter Sandman // Metallica
Piano Man // Billy Joel
Mama Mia // ABBA
Superstitious // Stevie Wonder
Come On Eileen // Dexy's Midnight Runners
Stand By Me // Ben E. King
I Will Survive // Gloria Gaynor
London Calling // The Clash
Forever Young // Alphaville
Roxanne // The Police
Every Breath you Take // The Police
Leaving on a Jet Plane // John Denver
Jailhouse Rock // Elvis Presley
Love me Tender // Elvis Presley
Blitzkrieg Bop // The Ramones
Mr Tambourine Man // Bob Dylan
Knockin' on Heavens Door // Bob Dylan
I Heard it Through the Grapevine // Marvin Gaye
Sweet Child O' Mine // Guns N' Roses
Rehab // Amy Winehouse
Hey Ya // Outkast
Stayin' Alive // Beegees

I should stop before I go to far... maybe I have already 

Ah, what the heck. I'll just count these votes anyway. 

In fact, I'll just abolish the rule where you can only vote up to 10 songs - you can now vote for as many songs as you like. 

All4One counts everything once he sees tons of prog and classic rock show up.

That's biased man.