Scratch

LOL

I just realised the chord progression of "Reload" is the same as in "My Dream Girl Don't Exist", a Neutral Milk Hotel song about a suicidal five year old

Techno, could you send me the master tracks without the vocals for My Voice to You and When I'm Beside You so that I can have them ready once we find a good female vocalist? Thanks.

veggieman001 wrote:

DIY wrote:

veggieman001 wrote:

LOL

I just realised the chord progression of "Reload" is the same as in "My Dream Girl Don't Exist", a Neutral Milk Hotel song about a suicidal five year old

I just listened to that song and I fail to see how it sounds anything like it. 

And the chord progression is nothing like the one in Reload. Are you sure you're referring to the correct song?

Yeah it is.
E B C#m A
Definitely the same chords
They don't sound too alike overall, but it just amuses me 

As far as I am concerned, that song uses A E B C#m, and when transposed, it is E B F# G#m. Those are not the chords.

veggieman001 wrote:

DIY wrote:

veggieman001 wrote:

Yeah it is.
E B C#m A
Definitely the same chords
They don't sound too alike overall, but it just amuses me 

As far as I am concerned, that song uses A E B C#m, and when transposed, it is E B F# G#m. Those are not the chords.

Which, Reload or Dreamgirl? Dreamgirl definitely has the chords
For Reload I'm just going off Noteflight

Nope, I listened to it. It is the chords I said before.

Look, this discussion is unnecessarily littering this thread once again. Let's leave it at this. 

veggieman001 wrote:

DIY wrote:

veggieman001 wrote:

Which, Reload or Dreamgirl? Dreamgirl definitely has the chords
For Reload I'm just going off Noteflight

Nope, I listened to it. It is the chords I said before.

Look, this discussion is unnecessarily littering this thread once again. Let's leave it at this. 

Uh no this clearly has those chords

and okay I guess because you always have to be right I'll shut up now

No, I am not always right. What a stupid remark to make. I happened to look at another source before, or a cover, picking it by ear. Please, don't approach me on that path. I hate it.

We don't need a female vocalist. ಠ_ಠ Not even a single one has auditioned, nor we know an active, good one.

@veggie, MVTY is here: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/99ba260a62c78b99529e070e193061079d009fed

And here is WIBY: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/85c0a48d4238d1a592f55943d7e768b089116bdd

EDIT: Also, I'm quite sure the chords for Reload are E - B - C#m - A through all the song. 

Last edited by technoguyx (2012-02-25 13:51:26)

Did anyone here me? I auditioned for a female vocalist! Thanks a1130.
I auditioned, and got on EVERY stink in' day.


Kk, I will 

Last edited by lundfamily3 (2012-02-25 18:05:11)

technoguyx wrote:

We don't need a female vocalist. ಠ_ಠ Not even a single one has auditioned, nor we know an active, good one.

@veggie, MVTY is here: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/99ba260a62c78b99529e070e193061079d009fed

And here is WIBY: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/85c0a48d4238d1a592f55943d7e768b089116bdd

EDIT: Also, I'm quite sure the chords for Reload are E - B - C#m - A through all the song. 

The first two songs are more suited to a female's voice and I think it would be awkward should a guy sing it. Plus, as a1130 has stated, lundfamily did audition, and she's pretty OK I believe.

And I was not referring to the chords of Reload being E B F# G#m. I meant the other song. I am already aware that Reload has E B C#m A. ಠ_ಠ

technoguyx wrote:

We don't need a female vocalist. ಠ_ಠ Not even a single one has auditioned, nor we know an active, good one.

@veggie, MVTY is here: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/99ba260a62c78b99529e070e193061079d009fed

And here is WIBY: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/85c0a48d4238d1a592f55943d7e768b089116bdd

EDIT: Also, I'm quite sure the chords for Reload are E - B - C#m - A through all the song.   

uh... no offense, but I don't think veggieman001's voice is appropriate for the songs. I listened to his recording and it doesn't sound "soothing" to put it lightly. TBH, it is quite mediocre (in the sense, it's harsh and unmelodious). I kinda agree with DIY that FC needs a female vocalist. I know I don't have much of a say in this because I'm just a stand-in musician, but I'm just saying.

veggieman001 wrote:

DIY wrote:

technoguyx wrote:

We don't need a female vocalist. ಠ_ಠ Not even a single one has auditioned, nor we know an active, good one.

@veggie, MVTY is here: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/99ba260a62c78b99529e070e193061079d009fed

And here is WIBY: http://www.noteflight.com/scores/view/85c0a48d4238d1a592f55943d7e768b089116bdd

EDIT: Also, I'm quite sure the chords for Reload are E - B - C#m - A through all the song. 

The first two songs are more suited to a female's voice and I think it would be awkward should a guy sing it. Plus, as a1130 has stated, lundfamily did audition, and she's pretty OK I believe.

And I was not referring to the chords of Reload being E B F# G#m. I meant the other song. I am already aware that Reload has E B C#m A. ಠ_ಠ

I don't really see how it would be 'awkward' per say. Neither song has any sort of reference to gender, though even if it did it still wouldn't really be awkward.

I do understand that they would probably be better with a female vocalist mostly because that's what you did at first, though. I think that, if you find a good one that can get good recording quality, it'll be amazing. 

Exactly my point. The band should push for a good vocalist with great recording quality.

And Locker, I totally agree with you.

Yep, veggie has a harsh voice. I think we could probably consider lundfamily, she seems pretty good.

BTW, I finished the piano part for Gone, it's here. It's kinda uneven still. I wish NoteFlight had a feature where it could count four beats before it started 

Why dont you include WIBY (original), WIBY, MVTY (original) and MVTY, then worry about the other songs.