Scratch

This has already been said no to, namely due to Scratches Motto "imagine . Program. Share"  By sharing your project on the scratch site, you automatically agree for Anyone to remix it     If you do not want this, simply upload the project to your own site following the instructions given Here!

Last edited by ssss (2011-02-26 07:18:15)

xSuGaR-MoNsTaRx wrote:

Its you! lol remember a few months ago we where gonna make a scratch game?
You want to make it again?
This time i wont quit lol

Yes, it's me...

What do you want to make?  I am up for anything... Some-one complained that the Offline/Online/Experimental viewer detector i made wasn't working - that was because they were using Flash Beta

there is a topic in Collabs http://scratch.mit.edu/forums/viewtopic … 28#p684128

Last edited by ssss (2011-02-26 07:33:35)

gohere

Yes, and ihaveamac already suggested it. The bill did not pass. 

This has been suggested many a time, and the general consensus is that disabling downloads would go against the principle of Scratch that anyone should be able to open up an interesting project and see how it works. The remix system is in place to be sure that everyone automatically gets credit for their work. Ripping off projects is an unfortunate side effect of this but it often helps to ask the user to stop!

Incidentally, this is on the list of commonly resolved (read: not happening) suggestions here. It's often helpful to check this list to see if your suggestion has been made already!

Ending on a geeky note, I personally don't see what the fuss is about when it comes to making projects "un-downloadable". Projects are downloaded by the player every time you open them online, and anyone who looks at the source code for the page can find the download URL for the project right there in the HTML -- it's there so the player knows which project to open and run.

xSuGaR-MoNsTaRx wrote:

i was thinking of a new idea for scratch --- un-downloadable projects ---
This would be a good idea because some people hate it when someone else remixes their projects... there should be an option which lets you make it downloadable, un-downloadable or make it so only your friends can download
Hope you like my idea =p

Flippynote Hatena (Flipnote Hatena)  is a MESS because of this.  Everyone locks their Flipnotes, and say, "give 50000 stars and ill unlock this." (sic).  This should NOT happen.  Besides, "imagine . Program . Share" .

Last edited by Rexpup (2011-03-30 19:48:42)

fullmoon wrote:

This has been suggested many a time, and the general consensus is that disabling downloads would go against the principle of Scratch that anyone should be able to open up an interesting project and see how it works. The remix system is in place to be sure that everyone automatically gets credit for their work. Ripping off projects is an unfortunate side effect of this but it often helps to ask the user to stop!

Incidentally, this is on the list of commonly resolved (read: not happening) suggestions here. It's often helpful to check this list to see if your suggestion has been made already!

Ending on a geeky note, I personally don't see what the fuss is about when it comes to making projects "un-downloadable". Projects are downloaded by the player every time you open them online, and anyone who looks at the source code for the page can find the download URL for the project right there in the HTML -- it's there so the player knows which project to open and run.

Fullmoon, it is not april fools yet!