I find that many of the same questions are asked (how do I scroll?) and often times people will write up their own explanation or guides. I don't think that this is needed since that are already tons of guides/posts/project explaining how to do things such as scrolling. A lot of the time you even get people advertising their own guide projects which just promotes attention mongering over helping people.
I think people should be linking others to already developed and well made guides. Sadly, there many guides are hard to find or burried deep away (like the old forum sticky guides) so people keep asking the same questions with different answers every time.
I think that the wiki could be a good place for directing people since it is (more or less) open to editing. With many people helping out there will not be any sloppy or bad guides (lots of "helpful" posts are poorly written I find) because everyone can combine their knowledge to make the guides the best they can be.
Lots of the old forum guides could be added to the wiki which would make it easier to find stuff
http://scratch.mit.edu/forums/viewtopic.php?id=37561
I think that the scratch community needs to get in the habit of refering people to these guides for help. Not only would this reduce clutter, it would deliver better help to those who want it.
Last edited by archmage (2010-08-03 14:23:04)
Offline
Offline
So any thoughts on what I posted or are you content with just making links where ever you can?
Offline
Great thoughts here! I definitely think linking is a great option for commonly asked questions, like scrolling. I have a pretty good memory, so if I know I've answered a specific question before, I'll search through my older posts until I find it. Additionally, if I can't answer the question myself, I'll redirect them to a topic that will explain it.
Thanks for reinforcing this!
Offline
Yeah, in some programming communities pointing people to links is the standard response for answering simple FAQs. I don't know if this will become common practice in the scratch community but I think it would be a good thing. I think that one issue would be that most forum users are too detached from the programming side of the forums so they can't deal properly with programming questions.
It would be good if mods like yourself reminded people to refer to the wiki or other established sources for answers to FAQs.
Offline
Yeah - I really want more people to appreciate the hard work we put into the wiki and such.
Offline
Yeah, I think I was the one who created the tutorial section. Scratch already has quite a few useful guides listed in Lightn's thread but very few are on the wiki. More are going up on the wiki so hopefully the wiki will have them all soon.
Offline
Thanks for creating tutorials. It would be great if they are more prominently linked in the Wiki and for people to start linking to them from the forums and comments in projects. I added the wiki to the Google custom search.
Offline