turtlewarrior wrote:
JeffreySterling wrote:
If we need more, you and I could enter our best and judge each others or something...? Or we could wait till we have 32 projects...? >:\
Naw, it's fine. It just means we'll have a pretty long contest
ok

(notice Hobbes's smile in the last panel...
)Offline
Starts tomorrow. I'll send a message to everyone in the contest tomorrow.
The first tier's first round shall begin very soon! The match up for Round 1, Section 1, Stage 1, Tier 1, is...
Scratch World by Louis 2018 VS Curveball by Marcsteen! This was totally random. So, judges, when you are ready, look at each project, and give them a rating from 1 to 10.
Remeber to...
Focus on whether you had fun
Give many reasons why you liked/didn't like it
Focus on the usefulness (if it is supposed to have some)
Focus on quality and originality
Give what you think it desserves!
Last edited by turtlewarrior (2010-03-01 18:00:15)
Offline
here is my entry form:
ScratchGenius7
1) http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/ScratchGenius7/865926
2) http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/ScratchGenius7/825300
Offline
Can the entries be an awesome picture you drew? Also, I am very young so well some people are way more experienced so does age count? I mean my projects are age appropriate. I'm not a scratch genius!
Offline
I entered! Check it out! Also, when will you start judging????????????
Do judges get a prize????????
Offline
ScratchGenius7 wrote:
Can the entries be an awesome picture you drew? Also, I am very young so well some people are way more experienced so does age count? I mean my projects are age appropriate. I'm not a scratch genius!
Lol, brilliant
Last edited by Kileymeister (2010-03-01 20:25:24)
Offline
ScratchGenius7 wrote:
Can the entries be an awesome picture you drew? Also, I am very young so well some people are way more experienced so does age count? I mean my projects are age appropriate. I'm not a scratch genius!
please answer this question on a link to a project not on the forum. i rarely check out forums
Offline
Kileymeister wrote:
ScratchGenius7 wrote:
Can the entries be an awesome picture you drew? Also, I am very young so well some people are way more experienced so does age count? I mean my projects are age appropriate. I'm not a scratch genius!
Lol, brilliant
![]()
what do you mean be brilliant? like the idea was great
ill add u as a friend
Offline
ScratchGenius7 wrote:
Kileymeister wrote:
ScratchGenius7 wrote:
Can the entries be an awesome picture you drew? Also, I am very young so well some people are way more experienced so does age count? I mean my projects are age appropriate. I'm not a scratch genius!
Lol, brilliant
![]()
what do you mean be brilliant? like the idea was great
ill add u as a friend
I mean that joke, "I'm not a scratch genius!" That line was brilliant!
Offline
ScratchGenius7 wrote:
Kileymeister wrote:
ScratchGenius7 wrote:
Can the entries be an awesome picture you drew? Also, I am very young so well some people are way more experienced so does age count? I mean my projects are age appropriate. I'm not a scratch genius!
Lol, brilliant
![]()
what do you mean be brilliant? like the idea was great
ill add u as a friend
Look at your username.
Yes, you can enter anything. The contest's author encourages this.
Last edited by technoguyx (2010-03-02 07:21:43)
Offline
Ok, I have thoroughly analized the first two projects:
Scratch World:
This was fun, I enjoyed it alot! I can tell that Louis2018 spent a lot of time on this. It didn't seem very useful to me, just fun.
I think I have seen a few projects with the same theme, but the quality was very good. I couldn't figure out how to do the mailman job though.
Overall, I gave this project a..................................7!
Curveball:
I really love this game! The visibility was not so great though, maybe if the "paddle" was nearly transparent, it would be better. It was just a pong game, not very useful, but very addicting!!! I love the 3D effect, but the game is pretty much just like ping pong.
Overall I gave this project a.........................................8!
GREAT JOB LOUIS2018 AND MARCSTEEN!!

(notice Hobbes's smile in the last panel...
)Offline
I'm voting now.
Curveball: Wow, this was surprisingly good. I honestly can't think of many things there could be an improvement on. Still, there were just tiny things that weren't perfect, but overall it was amazing! 9/10
Scratch World: Okay, pretty good. Maybe if the cat moved faster. I don't have a huge attention span, so holding one button for a long time was a little boring. Minigames were fun! 7.5/10
Now we just need mininut to get the results and destroy the world. I mean, move on to the next round *cough cough*
Offline
Wait, lol. I wanna switch out one of my projects for a new one!
My Two new Projects are:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/TheSaint/911850
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/TheSaint/788200
Offline
What about the other judge?
Offline
calebxy wrote:
What about the other judge?
We are waiting for the other judge, mininut4

(notice Hobbes's smile in the last panel...
)Offline
calm down people i was at school all day.
curveball: it was very good but i've seen it on a different website. it's also kind of hard to control the ball. 7-8. good job!
scratch world: good game. very fun. but i have ADHD so i have a short attantion span, (look a bird, just kidding) so if it moved faster. also when you buy things you don't lose money. if you want i could fix that. 5-6. good game.
you win my vote, marcsteen!
Offline
TheSaint wrote:
Wait, lol. I wanna switch out one of my projects for a new one!
My Two new Projects are:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/TheSaint/911850
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/TheSaint/788200
Too late , that's impossible now. I'm not making anymore changes.
Offline
Okay, it's unanimous! The winner of round 1 is...
MARCSTEEN! Yay! As the winner, you will receive negative 32 dollars, and a pass to stage 2! Huzzah! But don't worry Louis, you still receive a trophy of king kong and a taco made of dead people! Yay!
Now for Round 2 of Stage 1 of Section 1 of Tier 1 of Your Best Projects CONTEST #2 *gasp*
The contestants are...
Human Body RPG by mkolpnji and Disaster by Kileymeister
This wasn't totally random. I picked games I thought were near the same quality. Well, let's start this voting buisness.
======================ANNOUNCEMENT===================================
This applies to the judges. Once during the contest (and only once) you can use something called a Cik. When voting if you want to use up your Cik this allows you, for the round, to vote up to fifteen points. For example, if you see that there is 1 project with 13 Total Point Score (TPS) and the other has 26 TPS and you really think the first should win, type "I want to use my Cik, and I vote 14/10" than the TPS of that will be 27, and that project will win. If you have no Idea what I'm talking about, ignore this completely.
Last edited by turtlewarrior (2010-03-02 17:41:16)
Offline
turtlewarrior wrote:
TheSaint wrote:
Wait, lol. I wanna switch out one of my projects for a new one!
My Two new Projects are:
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/TheSaint/911850
http://scratch.mit.edu/projects/TheSaint/788200Too late , that's impossible now. I'm not making anymore changes.
Awww.
Offline
turtlewarrior wrote:
Okay, it's unanimous! The winner of round 1 is...
MARCSTEEN! Yay! As the winner, you will receive negative 32 dollars, and a pass to stage 2! Huzzah! But don't worry Louis, you still receive a trophy of king kong and a taco made of people! Yay!
Now for Round 2 of Stage 1 of Section 1 of Tier 1 of Your Best Projects CONTEST #2 *gasp*
The contestants are...
Human Body RPG by mkolpnji and Disaster by Kileymeister
This wasn't totally random. I picked games I thought were near the same quality. Well, let's start this voting buisness.
Sweet.
Bring it on, mkolpnji! >:D
Offline
I'll kick things off. The other judges might not get around to it today though.
Human Body RPG: Again, pretty good. Original, fun, educational, obviously has a lot of work put into it, useful. 9.5/10
Disaster: Almost as good as Human Body Rpg. Excellent graphics, fun, although really slow, and sometimes glitchy, even when downloaded. Still, you get a 9.1/10
Offline
i don't know what to do so im just going to start telling my opinion.
disaster: i didn't really like it to much. i did like that there was a freeplay however (i love playing around in freeplays). i didn't like how slow it was, but i appresiate that you mentioned it in the notes. you should have given instructions on controls. so about a 4-5. not bad.
human body rpg: mabey i shouldn't judge for this one because i might be a little biased because my parents are nurses. but in my opinion it was a very good game. i liked how you used medical terms (are you a nurse or doctor). i had some trouble getting it to work. i also liked how you mixed fighting with luerning. in my opinion an 8-9. great job!
Offline
mininut4 wrote:
you should have given instructions on controls
Hmm? There is a "rules" button, the controls are there. For some reason no one clicks that button...
Last edited by Kileymeister (2010-03-02 18:31:07)
Offline
Hmm... I didn't think it deserved that either, but hey, that mininut's opinion.
Offline