Pages: 1
Topic closed
I'm in the middle of a re-do of one of my projects, and typically, when working on a game, I usually use the arrow keys as the basic keyboard commands for movements, the spacebar as the command for something else (ie. attacking). Keyboard design thus dictates that a player controls sprite movements with the right hand, other commands with the left hand.
It then dawned on me that almost every game controller does the opposite: it often places the direction buttons/pad on the left, other button commands on the right.
It made me wonder whether the keyboard adage of arrow keys+spacebar was in conflict with what most other gamers are used to, and whether or not to shift the keyboard commands for movement to keys WASD.
This finally leads me to ask:
If using a keyboard when playing a game, would you prefer the movement commands to be controlled with the right hand (arrow keys), or would you prefer to movement command be controlled with the left hand (WASD)?
EDIT: I made my decision to give users the option for using either arrow keys or WASD, but I still would like to keep this poll open out of the sheer curiosity of seeing other people's opinions on this issue
Votes:
Arrow Keys - 5
WASD - 2
Both - 2
Last edited by cheddargirl (2009-08-24 18:39:07)

Offline
That's a really good point!
Colkadome's Krazy Killer has the WASD keys, but Axeblade's Droid Army uses the arrow keys.
Personally, I prefer the arrow keys. After all, they are arrow keys.
Offline
I prefer WASD keys. They are MUCH easier.
Offline
If I were programming and had to choose between one or the other, I would just put in both and let the user choose which to use.
Offline
I agree with @archmage.
Offline
iamrpk wrote:
I prefer arrow keys, but you can use the "or" block so you can do both.
archmage wrote:
If I were programming and had to choose between one or the other, I would just put in both and let the user choose which to use.
Ah, I could do both! Why didn't I think about that? *facepalm* I think I'll just modify the scripts so player have the option of using WASD or arrow keys.
But I'll keep the poll open out of curiosity: I do find it interesting that some people are inclined to use the arrow keys because it's more visually appealing than WASD, regardless of their hand preference.

Offline
I'm ambidextrous, but my left hand is deformed (little fingers) so I prefer arrows.
Offline
WASD.....
I like fps games.
Strange how I still always make my games arrow keys.
Offline
Topic closed
Pages: 1